You’ve seen the headlines that Cop28 in Dubai has resulted in an unprecedented call to ‘transition away from fossil fuels’. So why were celebrations from developing countries and civil society so muted?
Countries on the front lines of the climate crisis fear that they are still being left to carry the costs, and sink beneath the waves. This global deal has to work for everyone, or it won’t work for any of us.
Here are ten takeaways.
1. No, this outcome is not enough to avert runaway climate change
Rather than a being a detailed plan to save the planet, the deal is a badly-drawn sketch on the back of an envelope.
It only ‘calls for’ a transition away from fossil fuels, rather than deciding on a full phase out. It makes no requirement of the world’s biggest polluters to act any faster than the lower income countries who have done little to cause climate change.
It doesn’t put in place any finance to deliver any of its goals. And it leans on debunked technologies that the fossil fuel industry use to delay their phase out.
This means that the package does not have a whole lot of structural integrity and does not do much to push the biggest, or pull the smallest, in the right direction.
2. But it may accelerate the stranding of fossil fuel assets
You might have seen people celebrating the ‘signal’ that Cop28’s call to ‘transition away from fossil fuels’ sends. What does that mean? Does it mean anything at all? Well, yes actually.
The outcome could indeed make waves in the distant boardrooms of banks, investors and asset managers.
For seven years, financial institutions have completely ignored the Paris Agreement’s goal of aligning their financial flows with low greenhouse gas emissions pathways, and have instead continued to provide trillions of dollars to the fossil companies fuelling the climate crisis.
But the call on countries to transition away from fossil fuels is more likely to hit investors’ bottom lines. Bank loans to coal, oil and gas developments in countries that undertake the transition might never be repaid.
Shares and investments in fossil resources that will never be exploited will lose their value. Financial actors are strange, stubborn and unpredictable pack animals. The sensible ones will be planning their fossil exit strategies right now, ahead of the stampede.
3. Appetite for climate action is not matched by willingness to fund it
There’s no such thing as a free climate target. Cop28 really showed that while the world’s appetite for climate action has moved significantly forward, its willingness to cover the costs lags behind.
The wealthiest countries refused to offer any new finance to help lower income counties to leapfrog the fossil fuel era.
Many developing countries – those already being pushed into debt by the spiralling cost of climate disasters – will now be forced to make impossible choices between economic security and climate action.
If rich countries had been willing to put real finance and fair timelines on the table, the outcome could have been much stronger.
Finding ways forward on climate finance, and how we can cover the costs for the world we want to build together, must now be part of every climate conversation.
4. Saudi Arabia was willing to move (a bit). The US was not
With Cop28 being held in the UAE, there has been plenty of discussion about the role of the Gulf States, and the fossil fuel industry’s influence on the talks.
Saudi Arabia emerged as the country holding out most strongly against language to phase out fossil fuels.
But in fact, according to sources in the negotiating rooms, the US was the country that refused point blank to allow any language on finance or fair timelines.
In the final hours of Cop28, the head of the UN Antonio Guterres and of UN climate change Simon Stiell, alluded to ‘arbitrary red lines’, ‘entrenched positions’, ‘blocking tactics’ and ‘landmines’. That gave us insights into how the big beasts were locking horns behind closed doors
Ultimately, the call to transition away from fossil fuels represented Saudi’s willingness to compromise, somewhat. But the lack of finance in the deal showed that the US walked away with most of what it wanted, and gave nothing in return.
5. Developing countries leave Dubai with little
Unfairness is getting more baked into climate talks with each passing year. In thrall to the powerful players, Cop28 barely registered the needs of the countries who have done so little to cause the climate crisis, yet who are suffering the worst impacts and bearing all the costs.
The Alliance of Small Island States criticised the final document as a ‘litany of loopholes’ and ‘an incremental advancement over business-as-usual, when what we really needed was an exponential step change in our actions and support’.
Finance and fairness are key to ensuring the whole world can get on board with the transition to a fossil-free future. But with developing countries feeling demoted to bystanders in their own negotiations, these essential components are nowhere to be found.
6. False solutions get a foot in the door
Most people who have done the maths understand that carbon markets, and technologies like carbon capture and storage, simply can’t solve the climate crisis.
But these dangerous distractions provide a lifeline to the fossil industry, who are desperate to repeat the disproven claim that it’s fine carry on burning their products as long as unicorns, sorry I mean ‘new technologies’, take emissions out the air afterwards.
Cop28’s text leaning on these debunked approaches proved a triumph of lobbying over science. Meanwhile, technical negotiations trying to develop rules to govern carbon markets collapsed, with weak drafts deemed dangerous and unfixable.
Efforts to regulate nonsensical concepts will pick up again next year
7. Adaptation is unfunded
Climate change is bringing erratic rainfall patterns, warming oceans, floods, droughts and stronger cyclones to developing countries.
It is causing crop failures, destroying homes and drying up water sources. Governments are desperate to scale up adaptation to help communities strengthen their resilience to these impacts.
But the money that should be coming from the rich countries that are causing the climate crisis, is not forthcoming. Rich counties deleted any language reassuring countries that they will get the support they need.
8. Loss and damage fund finally agreed
There was some good news on the first day of Cop, two long weeks ago. Technical negotiations that took place throughout 2023 put forward an imperfect but important proposal for a loss and damage fund.
Unusually, this proposal was agreed in the opening plenary, and some minor funding announcements began to trickle in. Nothing like what is needed, but a start.
For the first time ever we have a pot that can help countries to rebuild and recover in the aftermath of climate disasters.
We now need to see much more finance, and for the World Bank that was controversially agreed as host, to fix its ways of working so that it can deliver funds directly to the communities in need.
9. Thank civil society for the focus on fossil fuels
We have civil society to thank for the focus and immense pressure on fossil fuels at Cop28. Thousands of organisations strategically echoed the call together for a fossil fuel phase out through their lobbying, networking, stunts and media work, until this became the one big demand that everyone came to expect from Cop.
Although we didn’t get the language we needed, the call to ‘transition away from fossil fuels’ would not have happened without civil society.
10.Finance and fairness will be the goals at Cop29
Ultimately, the Cop28 outcome is deeply unfair, putting an equal burden on rich and lower income countries, requiring no additional action or finance from those that have caused the climate crisis even as the global south bears the spiralling costs of a warming planet.
Cop29 in Azerbaijan is set to agree a new global target on climate finance. Already we know that rich counties want to avoid doing their fair share.
Instead of actually providing grants, they’ll try to claim that loans should count as climate finance, that their own corporations’ activities should count as climate finance, and that their purchasing of carbon offsets should also count.
All of that will not only undercut real finance outcomes, but will deepen rich countries’ neo-colonial grip on the global south, exploiting and exporting yet more profit, under a climate mask.
But if we – all of us – are to have a chance of a safe future, we need the richest countries to move beyond narrowly defined set of self-interests at climate talks, and provide the real finance that can put us on a path for real cooperation and global climate action.
There is much to do to change the terrain of what is possible. But we need to work together to get the public and the politicians on board with the idea that if we want to save our planet from self-destruction, we may actually need to cover the costs.
Teresa Anderson is Action Aid’s global lead on climate justice
The post We have to fix unfairness: Ten takeaways from Cop28 appeared first on Climate Home News.
Climate Change
Ocean advocates warn COP31 agreement should not be read as geoengineering boost
With COP31 set to agree that governments should do more to protect the oceans, climate campaigners and diplomats have warned that this must not be interpreted as encouragement for “unproven” marine-based geoengineering techniques.
Oceans absorb about 30% of the world’s planet-warming carbon dioxide, reducing the impacts of climate change. Initial research suggests that they could absorb more if altered with through techniques like ocean alkalinity enhancement or ocean iron fertilisation, where iron is put in the ocean so that algae grows on it and sucks up carbon.
The initial draft of the COP31 cover text contains a goal to increase carbon dioxide removal in general. Some ocean advocates said the link between this and oceans has not and should not be made. This language is contentious, with the EU opposed, and may not be in the final decision.
A political call to action released yesterday by COP31 co-presidency Türkiye encourages countries to protect marine ecosystems like mangroves and seagrasses, recognising their carbon storage potential, but it avoids any mention of marine geoengineering techniques.
At a COP31 press conference on Tuesday, Palau’s ambassador Ilana Seid said her Pacific country supported strong language on the protection of oceans but is concerned about marine carbon dioxide removal. “A lot of the science there is unproven and we are cautioning against that,” she said.
The main deal being negotiated in Antalya is the first one since the release of a major scientific report by the UN Environment Programme (UNEP) saying that overshooting the 1.5C temperature limit is now unavoidable and that, to bring temperatures back down, some technologies that remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere will be needed.
Seid added that, while some CDR will be necessary, it should be “at the tail end of the equation” and should not become a substitute for reducing emissions, an argument echoed by UNEP’s chief Inger Andersen at an event in Antalya.
Uncertain impacts on nature
Marine Lecerf, head of international policy at Ocean and Climate Platform, told reporters at COP31 on Tuesday that she is wary about marine carbon removal techniques, and that COP31’s strong push for ocean solutions should focus on more proven actions that cut carbon emissions.
“There are many uncertainties surrounding [marine carbon dioxide removal’s] effectiveness, their scalability, their durability – but even more importantly, their potential adverse impact on nature,” she said.
A paper from earlier this year by the University of California and the US-based National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) shows that, while ocean iron fertilisation’s impacts on nature “remain poorly understood”, disturbances may be stronger in some regions – like the equatorial Pacific – and lesser in others, like the Southern Ocean in Antarctica.
Speaking next to Lecerf at a COP31 press briefing, former Canadian environment minister Steven Guilbeault said the focus should instead be on ocean solutions that have already been proven to work. “We can perhaps another day talk about those technologies if we’re going to need them,” he said.
Asked what solutions are available, young Samoan activist Brianna Fruean spoke of a project she saw at the pre-COP in Fiji last month where the villagers of Naidiri have stopped fishing in an area of their waters and are replanting coral that has been bleached.
All the planters are volunteers though, she told Climate Home News, squeezing it in around their day jobs. With funding, they could be paid for their work – which began in 2009 – and restores the reef much faster, she added.
Push for ocean roadmap that informs next global stocktake grows at COP31
More research needed?
But some ocean advocates support research into these techniques. Kilaparti Ramakrishna, oceans and climate advisor at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution – which helped organise the COP31 oceans pavilion – told Climate Home News in September that research should be conducted into these techniques.
Ramakrishna said these techniques “have great potential in taking the carbon out of the atmosphere” and that scientific studies show that “it works” on a small scale. But, he said, the impacts on the environment if it is scaled up to draw a billion tonnes of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere are poorly understood. “So, we need to figure that out,” he said.
Woods Hole is conducting ocean iron fertilisation on a 10 square kilometre area and monitoring it for two years. “We’re already doing field studies”, said Ramakrishna, adding “those are the kinds of things that make the ocean a hero in terms of solving the climate problem. But we should always be mindful that in solving one problem we don’t create other problems”.
Back in September, Ramakrishna defended Woods Hole’s work, saying it does not take corporate money for its marine geongineering studies but only philanthropic foundations or governmental grants. It seeks permits from governments which involves long conversations and consultations, he added.
Pushing back against criticism, he said: “Some environmental groups say ‘oh my god, that is really messing with the environment. We are messing with the ocean environment today. You know, we should be mindful of that.”
The post Ocean advocates warn COP31 agreement should not be read as geoengineering boost appeared first on Climate Home News.
Ocean advocates warn COP31 agreement should not be read as geoengineering boost
Climate Change
ARIA nominees Teen Jesus, Fred Leone, Ocean Alley make red carpet statement to save heritage-nominated Scott Reef from oil and gas drilling
SYDNEY, Wednesday 18 November 2026 — Song of the Year Nominees Ocean Alley, nominee and opening performer Fred Leone, Best Group, Best Rock Album Nominees Teen Jesus and the Jean Teasers, and Hall of Fame inductees Spiderbait are among several artists to wear “Save Scott Reef” turtle-shaped pins and t-shirts at the 2026 ARIA awards ceremony.
- Photos and videos of artists wearing Save Scott Reef pins and t-shirts will be uploaded here, or check the ARIA official share point here.
The “Save Scott Reef” pins and t-shirts, designed by Greenpeace Australia Pacific, bring a nationwide push to save heritage-nominated Scott Reef, located 270 kilometres off WA’s Kimberley coast, into the spotlight at Australia’s top music event.
Scott Reef is home to thousands of marine species, genetically unique green sea turtles and endangered pygmy blue whales but is threatened by oil and gas drilling proposed by multinational corporation Woodside.
Hannah Schuch, Senior Campaigner at Greenpeace Australia Pacific, said: “This Ausmusic Month, artists across generations and genres are amplifying the call of half a million people who have called on the Australian Government to save Scott Reef from Woodside’s reckless plans to drill for oil and gas.
“Scott Reef is an irreplaceable, iconic piece of Australian heritage that has evolved over 15 million years, it is a no-brainer for musicians and creatives to call for the protection of this incredible ecosystem.
“Woodside’s Scott Reef drilling plans threaten to cause the worst oil spill in Australian history, harm threatened turtles and whales, and add to the pressure on our overstressed oceans.
“We’ll all be winners if the government rejects Woodside’s plans and saves Scott Reef.”
It comes as Scott Reef released a debut single titled “If Not Now” alongside Jimmy Barnes, King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard and a supergroup of over 20 musicians, and over 150 Australian artists and entertainers, including Grammy-nominated Coachella headliner Kevin Parker, signed an open letter calling for Scott Reef’s protection.
Federal Environment Minister, Murray Watt, is expected to decide if Woodside will be allowed to drill at Scott Reef for the Browse oil and gas project in the coming months.
—ENDS—
Climate Change
COP31 Bulletin Day 9: Crunch ministerial talks planned for Wednesday evening
With just three official days of talks left, the catch-all initial draft of the cover decision – which the Arab Group and Russia say they reject – has yet to be slimmed down.
To speed things up, the COP31 presidency has asked governments to send their top people to a meeting at 5pm local time dubbed a “Divan”, a word derived from an Ottoman council.
There, they are being encouraged to respond to the question: “How can COP31 send signals and capture a clear plan of action which meets the moment, while respecting national circumstances and priorities?”
Participants are encouraged to speak directly to each other rather than just reading out statements to the chair, who – despite Australia’s role as President of Negotiations – will be COP31 President Murat Kurum.
The aim is to “explain where their delegations see room for common ground and what they would need to reach agreement” on a text that is intended to be the cherry on the cake of “a balanced package” including negotiated agenda items. A handful of observer groups will also be present in the room.
It is unclear whether the next version of the text will come out before or after the “Divan” meeting. The presidency has said only that it will be published as soon as possible.
COP31 Bulletin Day 8: EU backs electrification goal, as more TAFF roadmaps promised
Before then on Wednesday, we are expecting announcements from a group of countries aiming for net negative emissions and we will be hearing from the European Union again at a 2pm press conference. There will also be a ministerial event to launch the next Global Stocktake of national climate plans, which is due to conclude in 2028.
One hot issue that has angered developing countries and campaigners alike this week is the reluctance of rich nations to put significant amounts of new finance on the table in Antalya, especially for adaptation, at a time when the impacts of global warming are hitting ever harder. A pledging session on Tuesday saw measly contributions of just $50 million for the Adaptation Fund against its annual target of $300 million.
Panama minister: Consensus system dooms COPs to failure
Panama’s environment minister Juan Carlos Navarro told a press conference on Wednesday morning that COPs “are doomed to failure” because they rely on consensus.
“For heaven’s sake, how can 192 countries agree by consensus on how to fix a crisis that they created and that most of the developed nations and the producers of fossil fuels are responsible for?” he asked.
“Our hearts are full of hope and goodwill, but we are crashing against a wall of perverse futility and the most blatant inflexibility from those who should lead the way,” he said, before criticising COP delegates as “bureaucrats and moochers” and people on “paid vacations” who “fill the halls with AI-generated beautiful speeches”.
“It’s about time the world grows up, and each nation accepts individual responsibility and stops hiding behind the smoke curtain of COPs and the miraculous way which they supposedly will fix, in this international fora by consensus, problems which we know will not be fixed with these exercises in hypocrisy,” he blasted.


The UNFCCC has responded to calls for reform of the UN climate process including COPs by consulting with a panel of experts. In Antalya, countries have also been airing their views on the topic in presidency-led consultations, which has angered some governments like Russia and the Arab nations.
But abolishing the COP’s consensus-based system is unlikely because doing so would require consensus – which countries like Saudi Arabia have always fiercely opposed.
The African Group is also against changing the rules – which have never been formally adopted – to a more nimble way of operating such as by majority voting.
Its chair, Antwi-Boasiako Amoah of Ghana, defended veto power at the mid-year talks in June, telling journalists that “countries are sovereign, national interests are different, and you cannot sacrifice one party’s interest for another’s”.
Some governments that want to move faster on thorny issues such as phasing out fossil fuels have formed so-called coalitions of the willing outside the UN climate talks, such as the Santa Marta process which brings together around 60 countries that want to plan their transition away from coal, gas and oil.
The post COP31 Bulletin Day 9: Crunch ministerial talks planned for Wednesday evening appeared first on Climate Home News.
COP31 Bulletin Day 9: Crunch ministerial talks planned for Wednesday evening
-
Climate Change1 year ago
Guest post: Why China is still building new coal – and when it might stop
-
Greenhouse Gases1 year ago
Guest post: Why China is still building new coal – and when it might stop
-
Renewable Energy1 year agoSending Progressive Philanthropist George Soros to Prison?
-
Greenhouse Gases1 year ago
嘉宾来稿:探究火山喷发如何影响气候预测
-
Climate Change2 years agoAnalysis: China’s CO2 falls 1% in Q2 2024 in first quarterly drop since Covid-19
-
Climate Change1 year ago嘉宾来稿:探究火山喷发如何影响气候预测
-
Green Living2 years agoOur Picks for the Top 2024 Black Friday and Cyber Week Sales From Sustainable Brands
-
Renewable Energy5 months agoSend a Bible to a Starving Child

