Connect with us

Published

on

England will soon introduce one of the world’s most ambitious biodiversity policies in “Biodiversity Net Gain”.

This policy effectively mandates that any new development leaves biodiversity in a better state than before it was constructed. It was initially meant to go into effect in November, but the government has pushed back its implementation until 2024.

In order to understand the potential impacts of the Biodiversity Net Gain, our team has been tracking development projects approved over the last three years in six councils across England that were early adopters of the policy.

Our latest paper, published this month, reveals several fundamental challenges that threaten the integrity of the policy’s environmental and economic outcomes.

We find that the oversight, monitoring and enforcement of biodiversity improvements supposedly delivered under the policy need urgent attention.

For example, there is a clear “governance gap”, where the system for monitoring biodiversity gains delivered on the site of new developments is weaker than for gains purchased from elsewhere. The process is overseen by local planning departments, which are typically lacking in capacity and ecological expertise.

Biodiversity Net Gain is an essential pillar of the country’s plans for attracting private finance into nature conservation to achieve its overarching environmental objectives.

Ultimately, the challenges we identify threaten the integrity of one of England’s most important environmental markets – and with it, the environmental outcomes of the government’s nature markets strategy.

Biodiversity Net Gain

Under the Biodiversity Net Gain policy, developers have three ways to offset their “biodiversity liability” – the damage their project does to nature. Biodiversity Net Gain applies to most developments, such as housing and smaller infrastructure projects. The policy will apply to major infrastructure projects from 2025 onwards.

First, they can enhance biodiversity somewhere within the development – so-called “on-site” gains. These on-site gains can take the form of, for example, sowing wildflowers along road verges or managing some of the grassland within a housing development to promote wildlife, rather than for traditional landscaping.

If developers can’t meet their liabilities on-site, their second option is to use biodiversity “units” from ecological improvements elsewhere. Under the policy, these units are supposed to mirror the habitat that is impacted by the development, so that when developers damage habitats, they must replace them with habitats that are at least as valuable, from a conservation perspective, as those lost.

Some of these units might come from the new “net-gain market”. Land managers create these units by implementing conservation actions on their land, such as converting low-productivity pasture into a field managed for wildflowers. Then, they sell these units to developers.

Alternatively, some developers are developing their own habitat banks, creating biodiversity units in one place to offset the impacts of their developments elsewhere.

Last, if no units are available through either of these pathways, developers can buy “statutory biodiversity credits” directly from the national government.

These credits loosely resemble the units sold via the market. The government holds a stock of these units as a last resort for developers who cannot offset their damage in other ways. For example, they may offset damage to particularly rare types of habitat for which there may not be suitable credits available on the standard market.

Importantly, the price levels for these statutory units have been set deliberately high, in an attempt to disincentivise developers from relying on these credits.

The ‘governance gap’

Our dataset spans around 1,600 hectares of development footprint that have been submitted or approved for development over the last three years in these six early-adopter councils: West and South Oxfordshire, Vale of White Horse, Cornwall, Leeds City and Tunbridge Wells.

Mammoth cranes are all at work on Oxford's giant Westgate development project.
Mammoth cranes are all at work on Oxford’s giant Westgate development project. Credit: Jon Bower / Alamy Stock Photo.

Our team has been collating and analysing the biodiversity assessments submitted to these authorities for each project.

We’ve analysed the trades occurring under the policy and the rules that govern them. Additionally, we have quantified any errors embedded in the developers’ biodiversity assessments. Our research has identified several shortfalls that need addressing for this nature market to be able to deliver on its goals.

Our first key finding is that around one-quarter of all the biodiversity units delivered under the policy so far fall within a “governance gap” – meaning that they are likely to go unmonitored, and may even be legally unenforceable.

As a result, there is a very high probability that regulators will not be able to take any action if these promised gains are not delivered.

This will likely translate into a large chunk of these units not materialising in reality, as there is little incentive for developers to deliver these units in full if there is no credible enforcement mechanism.

The problem is that the standards and regulations of the three offset pathways vary considerably.

There is reasonably stringent governance to ensure that biodiversity units purchased on the offsetting market are delivered in reality. Sellers will have to submit their offsets to a national database, monitor biodiversity changes and report on the ecological development of the site at regular intervals.

Contrary to these standards, the system for monitoring, reporting and enforcing units delivered “on-site” is much weaker. The government has suggested that the existing planning enforcement system can be used to oversee on-site units.

The planning enforcement system was never designed for such a task, and in its current form, is unsuitable for fulfilling this role.

Under the current system, local authorities are explicitly advised to only take enforcement action, such as warnings or fines, if a developer’s violation of a planning condition results in “serious harm to a local public amenity”. Although it is unclear how this will apply to the Biodiversity Net Gain policy, the failure to deliver a habitat that a developer promised in a planning application a few years prior is extremely unlikely to trigger this threshold.

Developers also do not have to log their on-site gains on the national Biodiversity Net Gain register, which means that many of these projects are likely to go unmonitored. Even if they underperform relative to the original promise in the planning application, there is no credible system in place to hold developers to account for such non-delivery.

Risk of non-delivery

In our research, we have found that around one-quarter of all the units delivered under the policy are at a high risk of non-delivery because of this governance gap.

While the regulation of a specific kind of biodiversity unit within a single policy might sound unimportant, this actually has serious implications for how England’s nature markets function.

The core pillar of England’s ambitions for drawing private finance into nature conservation is the Biodiversity Net Gain market. Any biodiversity units that are delivered on-site by developers are units they will not need to purchase from the off-site market. So the less stringent the standards in the on-site system, the more this will drain demand for units from the off-site market, which is relatively more ecologically robust.

Although we recognise our data is preliminary, we estimate that if these under-regulated biodiversity units were to be delivered via the off-site market instead, the demand for biodiversity units could rise by a factor of four.

This could significantly increase the amount of conservation implemented on private land and, therefore, the amount of private finance flowing into conservation projects on private land.

New housing development on the edge of Hunstanton, Norfolk.
New housing development on the edge of Hunstanton, Norfolk. Credit: UrbanImages / Alamy Stock Photo.

There is precedent for this. The English scheme was partially informed by the US wetland mitigation markets. In 2008, those markets underwent reform to address a similar governance gap.

In the US case, the standards applied to developer-led and third-party projects diverged enormously, meaning a range of low-quality mitigation projects were being implemented by developers. The 2008 compensation rule in the US wetland mitigation system addressed this disparity by ensuring that the same standards were applied across all forms of compensation.

Lacking capacity

Our research also reveals other interesting, consequential patterns. Perhaps the most important to the integrity of this emerging market is the current lack of capacity in local authorities to be able to deliver on the Biodiversity Net Gain policy.

Local authorities do the best they can with the resources they have, but they have undergone stringent funding cuts since 2008.

At the last count, around 60% of local planning authorities have no in-house ecological expertise – which is essential for delivering biodiversity gains effectively.

In our study, we evaluated how many of the applications contained a basic error in their calculations: we checked to see if the area of the site before and after development added up to the same amount.

We found that the areas did not add up in around one-fifth of all projects. Of these, around half had already been accepted by the local planning authorities. One explanation for this oversight could be that planners were so rushed they did not have time to examine the calculations included with the application.

This suggests we have not yet addressed the serious capacity shortages in the councils – who are ultimately going to be the public bodies overseeing the delivery of Biodiversity Net Gain at local scales. This is clear evidence that further investment in local planning capacity is required.

Environmental markets have the potential to be powerful mechanisms for improving nature, but one of the fundamental features of biodiversity compensation markets is that they deliver biodiversity gains that make up for an equal and opposite loss elsewhere.

This means that every biodiversity unit that is promised by developers in order to secure planning permission, but then not delivered in reality, has legitimised the loss of biodiversity elsewhere.

Making sure that these policies lead to direct, robust gains in the quality of nature is therefore absolutely essential to ensure that the markets-focused approach to drawing private finance into nature recovery in England leaves the environment better, rather than worse, off.

The post Guest post: Fixing the gaps in England’s ‘biodiversity net-gain’ policy appeared first on Carbon Brief.

Guest post: Fixing the gaps in England’s ‘biodiversity net-gain’ policy

Continue Reading

Climate Change

‘COP-out’: COP31 fails to deliver the ambition needed to phase out fossil fuels and address climate breakdown

Published

on

Antalya, Türkiye, Sunday 22 November 2026 — The COP31 climate summit in Antalya has ended in disappointment and anger, as the final COP31 outcome failed to deliver on critical issues like overshooting the 1.5°C limit, fossil fuel phase out and climate finance. Greenpeace Australia Pacific says that Australia did not deliver the deal that the world needed in a time of escalating climate breakdown.

In Antalya, Dr Susie Byers, Head of Advocacy at Greenpeace Australia Pacific, said: “We need to call this COP outcome what it is: a COP-out that has failed to deliver what the world urgently needs given the scale of the crisis we’re facing. It’s a colossal lost opportunity, and one that the world won’t easily forget.

“Coming out of Belém there was momentum to phase out fossil fuels, but COP31 wasn’t able to harness that energy and drive the world forward. The failure to adopt the Cover Decision means there’s now no acknowledgement of, let alone response to, 1.5°C overshoot — the survival line for Pacific nations. Electrification, defence of science, protection for the oceans, and advances on climate finance were all casualties of cynical attempts to derail climate action with dangerous distractions like CCUS.

“Australia knew how hard this task would be and put their hand up anyway. In the end, they didn’t get it done. This outcome validates exactly why so many countries are looking towards parallel tracks like the International Court of Justice Advisory Opinion and national transition roadmaps, where we’ve seen microdiplomacy and Pacific leadership again lead the way. This spirit of multilateralism and collaboration is how we will move beyond rhetoric to concrete actions, and end the fossil fuel chokehold.”

Also in Antalya, Shiva Gounden, Head of Pacific at Greenpeace Australia Pacific, said: “They called this an ‘implementation’ COP, but implementation means nothing when the foundation is broken. The frontline communities leading this fight came to Antalya demanding the urgent, definitive action required to confront the sickening realities of 1.5°C overshoot. Instead, developed countries turned their backs on their historical responsibilities, held climate finance hostage, and treated the debt they owe as a cheap bargaining chip.

“At the exact same time, Parties and negotiating blocs deliberately blocked the bold action the world needed on mitigation, peddled toxic distractions like CCUS, and intentionally scrubbed the words ‘fossil fuels’ from the final text. A strong Presidency that understood the urgency of the situation would not have let this happen; Australia failed to deliver what it promised the Pacific.

“Billions of people across the world are fiercely defending their lives, their homes, their cultures, and their livelihoods, and we came here with their voices demanding real action. By choking off the money and refusing to name the root cause of this collapse, polluting nations made a calculated choice to protect their own interests over our shared future. The Pacific will increasingly look towards parallel paths like the ICJ climate advisory opinion, and the Santa Marta process, to continue finding solutions because that is what our people need.”

ENDS
COP31 images and video available here in Greenpeace Media Library

Media contact: Kate O’Callaghan in Antalya (GMT+3) on +61 406 231 892 (Whatsapp/Signal)

‘COP-out’: COP31 fails to deliver the ambition needed to phase out fossil fuels and address climate breakdown

Continue Reading

Climate Change

COP31 Bulletin Day 13: New draft retains electrification goal but delays adaptation finance and science decisions

Published

on

After an evening of tense discussions, a new version of the cover text was finally released at around 2am on Sunday morning. But, with many delegates flying home, it is unclear if – and for how long – there will be the two-thirds of governments present needed to legally adopt a decision.

The latest draft, which is – as of 9.30 – scheduled to be put to a plenary session for approval at 10am – retains a goal to boost electrification and links it more strongly with clean energy and storage. It does not, however, include language on transitioning away from fossil fuels as many countries had called for.

It ditches a specific numerical target for carbon capture, use and storage (CCUS), a controversial technology that is favoured by fossil fuel producers, which is now only an aim “to achieve gigatonne scale globally by 2035 as a collective global aspiration”. The previous version had two alternative targets, a weaker one of 0.5Gt “working towards” 1.3-2.5Gt and a stronger one of 2.5Gt.

The draft cover decision has strong language on responding to an almost certain overshoot of the 1.5C warming limit, recognising that it will increase loss and damage and result “in increasingly adverse, and in some cases irreversible, impacts and risks to human and natural systems”. As President of Negotiations Chris Bowen has repeatedly drawn attention to, this is the first COP held since the UN acknowledged that overshoot is inevitable.

In pursuing efforts to limit any overshoot, the decision recognises the need for “deep, rapid and sustained reductions in greenhouse gas emissions in line with 1.5 °C pathways” – which is a push towards greater ambition.

The text also resolves to close adaptation gaps and boost action and support to help countries and communities to better cope with adverse climate impacts. But it does not put a figure to a goal agreed at COP30 last year to triple adaptation finance by 2035.

The goal did not specify a baseline year and African nations, least-developed countries and small island states had pushed for it to be a later and higher baseline and therefore a larger target number of $120 bn a year. Instead, the text launches a “roadmap” on adaptation finance to be considered at COP32.

Loss and damage finance has been cut from the roadmap’s scope, as have references to about half the money pledged to the loss and damage fund having yet to be sent to the fund’s bank account and the gap between the $2.8 billion of loss and damage funding requested by developing countries in the fund’s start-up stage and the $0.342 billion allocated to fund these projects. “Erasing the shortfall doesn’t make it disappear for families who have lost everything”, said Harjeet Singh, global convenor of Fill the Fund.

The new text drops its invitation to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) to publish all of its next three reports in time for the 2028 global stocktake of climate progress. Instead, it just invites them to “continue to provide policy-relevant information as input to the UNFCCC processes, including outputs from the seventh assessment cycle to the next global stocktake”. It no longer specifies that all their reports, including the third on reducing emissions, are published. The IPCC will have an online meeting in December to discuss this issue but COP31 guidance will be influential in its decision.

As Climate Home News entered the venue around 7.30am, tired-looking negotiators from Saudi Arabia and from the Alliance of Small Island Developing States were seen entering the area which houses the Presidency’s offices, as others dozed on sofas. A source close to the German delegation said that negotiations had been intense and were not necessarily resolved.

If the Presidency does not think it can get agreement on a cover text, then it can withdraw it or it can issue it a Presidency declaration, which does not have much weight. Some of its provisions could be added into other agenda items and adopted seperately. Governments could also decide to reconvene COP31 at a later date – known as a bis – as happened at COP6.

The post COP31 Bulletin Day 13: New draft retains electrification goal but delays adaptation finance and science decisions appeared first on Climate Home News.

COP31 Bulletin Day 13: Germany rejects text moments before plenary meeting

Continue Reading

Climate Change

COP31 Bulletin Day 12: ‘Don’t ignore us,’ Panama warns as COP31 runs into overtime

Published

on

On Friday night, COP31 approved a series of less controversial agenda items and then COP President Murat Kurum told governments to hang around the venue until midnight in case his team wanted to consult them on the cover text, which is still Thursday’s version.

If you don’t hear from us, Kurum said, go home and get some rest and don’t bother coming in before 9am. Governments appear to have taken his advice. Around 10am, the conference centre was ghostly and there was still no sign of a new draft cover text.

COP31 Bulletin Day 11: Countries decry cover text for omitting fossil fuels 

Friday night’s plenary did offer a few moments of drama. An activist was ushered out of the room by security after holding a rope around his neck and shouting “you keep doing nothing, nothing at all” and “you are killing the future, just kill me now” to a smattering of applause.

An activist stages a lone protest in the COP31 plenary room during a session on November 20, 2026. (Photo: © UN Climate Change – Kiara Worth)

An activist stages a lone protest in the COP31 plenary room during a session on November 20, 2026. (Photo: © UN Climate Change – Kiara Worth)

Panama’s environment minister Juan Carlos Navarro urged Kurum to ensure full respect of the rules of procedure when gavelling decisions through this weekend. Given he has led threats to object to the cover text if it is not ambitious enough, this sounded like a warning to Kurum not to ignore objections, as previous COP presidents have been accused of doing.

Another significant development on Friday night was a joint statement from Australia and China which, among other things, expressed China’s backing for the 35×35 electrification goal. More on that here.

The post COP31 Bulletin Day 12: ‘Don’t ignore us,’ Panama warns as COP31 runs into overtime appeared first on Climate Home News.

COP31 Bulletin Day 12: ‘Don’t ignore us,’ Panama warns as COP31 runs into overtime

Continue Reading

Trending