Connect with us

Published

on

 Dhanush Dinesh is the founder of Clim-Eat, a think-and-do-tank for food and climate.

When the Stade de France in Paris is filled to capacity, it holds 81,400 people. You would then need another 2,484 to reach the number of badge-wearing participants at last year’s UN COP28 climate change conference in Dubai. This illustrates the sheer size of what was the world’s most important climate-focused event in 2023. 

But it also begs the question, do these annual ‘mega-gatherings’ actually deliver anything? 

One thing is abundantly clear: despite almost three decades of COPs and ballooning attendance, our greenhouse gas emissions continue to rise, and the world continues to warm. 

Process hijacking purpose  

My colleagues and I at Clim-Eat – the think-and-do-tank for food and climate that I founded in 2021 – recently published a paper examining the efficacy of COP summits, specifically in relation to food and agriculture. We found several failures. 

Firstly, negotiations on food and agriculture have moved at a snail’s pace over the past 17 years. In spite of numerous meetings, workshops, submissions and decisions, there has been literally no real-world impact as a result.  

Secondly, the trend of COP host countries – known as Presidencies – launching special initiatives on specific issues of interest has achieved little. These initiatives receive plenty of media attention when announced but amount to little more than virtue signalling. 

Rich nations meet $100bn climate finance goal – two years late

For example, at the launch of COP21’s 4p1000 Initiative, France’s then-Minister of Agriculture said it could reconcile aims of food security and the fight against climate change. Today, the initiative has yet to report anything on the positive climate action it sought to create.  

The same goes for Morocco’s COP22 initiative on Adaptation in African Agriculture. It no longer mentions its ambitious target of raising $30 billion to support farmers – presumably because it hasn’t been reached. There are plenty of other examples of special initiatives being quietly ushered out of the spotlight.  

Unwarranted optimism

Let’s remember that COP negotiations first recognised agriculture as the key to solving climate change in 2006. It then took six years to agree on the next steps. Then, only in 2022, 16 years after the initial point, did the negotiations agree that “socioeconomic and food security dimensions are critical when dealing with climate change in agriculture and food systems.” Sixteen years to build a sentence to combat a third of global emissions.  

This suggests there’s little reason to be optimistic about the Emirates Declaration on Food and Agriculture, a special initiative launched at last year’s COP28. Signed by 159 countries, it called for action to adapt food systems to climate change, but the summit’s official negotiations on food and agriculture failed to acknowledge the declaration or reflect its priorities. The declaration itself is a creative collection of various adjectives and adverbs, reaffirmations and goals to ‘strengthen’ commitments. And six months after its launch, it is not clear whether it has led to anything at all; placing faith in its outcomes is utterly fanciful. 

The path forward

This cycle of the UNFCCC and COP Presidencies applauding special initiatives in the short term without holding countries responsible in the long term has to stop. The hamster wheel of inaction continues to spin.  

But we can slow it down and perhaps get off the wheel altogether. To do this, my colleagues and I concluded that the UN needs to: 

  • Reform the UNFCCC process to prioritise measurable results and impacts, shifting its role to that of a watchdog ensuring action from all actors rather than merely organising large, costly meetings. 
  • Make COPs leaner and less frequent/hold them every other year, reducing participant numbers and focusing on productive meetings. 
  • Increase transparency regarding the financial costs of COPs, participation and emissions, to hold the UN accountable. 

Implementing these recommendations will not be easy. It means changing entrenched ways and tackling entrenched interests. There will be push-back.  

But as the UN’s mid-year climate talks begin in Bonn this week, observe the promises made with little follow-through, the unwarranted yet celebratory atmosphere filling the air – largely destined to be forgotten. Notice that when the clapping has stopped, and the initiators are no longer in the spotlight, they will slink back into the shadows, waiting to resurface onto the next grand stage at COP29 in Azerbaijan.  

The post The great COP food systems illusion: UN climate talks deliver no real-world action appeared first on Climate Home News.

The great COP food systems illusion: UN climate talks deliver no real-world action

Continue Reading

Climate Change

Kevin Parker, Hugh Jackman, Tina Arena and over 150 Australian artists sign open letter to save Scott Reef from Woodside gas plans

Published

on

SYDNEY, Monday 16 November 2026 — More than 150 Australian entertainers and creatives have signed an open letter calling on Federal Environment Minister Murray Watt to reject oil and gas drilling plans at Scott Reef, Australia’s largest oceanic reef system.

  • Artists have supplied images for use here
  • High res images and footage of Scott Reef can be found here

The open letter to Minister Watt concerns risks to Scott Reef, 270 kilometres from the Kimberley coast of Western Australia, posed by multinational Woodside which plans to drill up to 57 wells for its Browse gas project. The project is forecast to emit 1.6 billion tonnes of climate pollution and risk a catastrophic oil spill in endangered whale migratory pathways.

Australian signatories calling on the government to save Scott Reef include 2026 ARIA nominees Kevin Parker (Tame Impala), Tkay Maidza and G Flip, Hollywood actors Hugh Jackman and Simon Baker, and prolific musicians Tina Arena, Paul Kelly and “Down Under” legends Men at Work.

About the open letter, Australian musician Jessica Mauboy said: “Caring for Country means caring for our oceans and all the life they hold. Places like Scott Reef are precious, and we have a responsibility to protect them for future generations. I’m adding my voice to the call to protect Scott Reef and keep it safe from gas drilling.”

Australian singer-songwriter and ARIA award winner Missy Higgins signed the open letter and said: “Scott Reef is an ancient coral reef off WA’s Kimberley coast, home to endangered whales, vulnerable turtles and hundreds of other marine species. Woodside’s plans to drill up to 57 wells under and around it put this extraordinary place at risk. We need to preserve these beautiful places for our kids. If not now, then when?”

Australian singer-songwriter Sarah Blasko said: “Scott Reef off Western Australia’s Kimberley Coast is not the place for a massive new gas project by Woodside. It’s our responsibility to protect our beautiful reefs and rare marine life. They are, after all, what this country is best known for around the world. If we don’t protect them, what does it say about us to our children and the world?”

Scott Reef supports thousands of species including vulnerable turtles and endangered whales that are particularly threatened by Woodside’s proposal. Greenpeace has nominated Scott Reef for National Heritage listing for its ecological and scientific importance, and the WA Environment Protection Authority (WA EPA) has warned Woodside’s plans could cause “serious, significant and irreversible” harms to the 15-million-year-old ecosystem.

Senior Campaigner at Greenpeace Australia Pacific, Hannah Schuch, said: “I am heartened to see so many Australian artists amplifying the call for a better future, one where places like Scott Reef are rightfully protected from greedy corporate interests.

“Scott Reef is an iconic, irreplaceable piece of Australian nature, and Woodside’s plans to drill 57 toxic wells and turn Scott Reef into an industrialised gas zone risk threatened species and this unique, ancient ecosystem.

“Murray Watt and the Albanese Government have an opportunity to make history and write their legacy: save Scott Reef and stop Woodside’s reckless gas plans. Australia is watching.”

-ENDS-

Media contact

Emma Sangalli on 0431 513 465 or emma.sangalli@greenpeace.org

Kevin Parker, Hugh Jackman, Tina Arena and over 150 Australian artists sign open letter to save Scott Reef from Woodside gas plans

Continue Reading

Climate Change

Behind the COP31 fanfare, Türkiye is worried about water

Published

on

Efe Baysal leads the Türkiye team of global climate advocacy group 350.org. 

As Türkiye welcomed world leaders in Antalya during the first week of the UN climate summit, few were probably aware that wildfires raged just a few kilometres from the COP31 venue in September, injuring several people and forcing hundreds to flee their homes.

Wildfires are one of the signs of a rapidly heating planet. Prolonged heatwaves and drought create ideal conditions for fires to start and to spread. In the coastal province of Antalya, 8,000 hectares have already been lost to forest fires this year alone.

It is a crucial moment for climate diplomacy. This year we have seen the human cost and mounting economic damage of climate impacts, from Europe’s heatwaves to Nepal’s deadly glacial floods. Scientists warn that the world will breach the 1.5C temperature limit within a few years.

    The stakes have never been higher as the Turkish government takes its turn hosting the Conference of the Parties (COP) to the UN climate convention. Türkiye has a lot riding on the summit, and not only its ability to stage one. Many in the country hope COP31 will put a spotlight on its own climate and environmental crisis.

    Extreme weather in Türkiye is becoming far more frequent. In 2011, the country recorded more than 300 extreme weather events. By 2023, according to the Turkish State Meteorological Service, the figure had reached almost 1,500.

    Dried-up lakes and sinkholes

    For a semi-arid country, drought is a particular threat. Half of Türkiye’s population is at risk of water shortages by 2030, and last year brought the lowest rainfall in 61 years.

    Perhaps the starkest sign of this is the alarming rate at which Türkiye’s lakes are vanishing. Three-quarters of its lakes have dried up in the past 50 years, many of them just in the last decade, marking the loss of ecological systems that have sustained generations of farmers and fishermen. 

    An example is Lake Iznik, the country’s fifth-largest natural lake and the site of the Byzantine Basilica of Saint Neophytos, a fifth-century site whose ruins were first discovered underwater. When Pope Leo visited last year, they stood exposed on dry land as the shoreline had dramatically retreated.

    A drone view shows the remains of the sunken Byzantine Basilica of Saint Neophytos by Lake Iznik, Turkey, November 21, 2025. REUTERS/Kemal Aslan

    A drone view shows the remains of the sunken Byzantine Basilica of Saint Neophytos by Lake Iznik, Turkey, November 21, 2025. REUTERS/Kemal Aslan

    Locals fear that due to drought, as well as the pumping of large volumes of water by big agricultural companies, Lake Iznik will disappear. As Iznik recedes, the coastal water wells that irrigate olive groves have run dry.

    “Everyone stands over their phones waiting for weather forecasts, wondering, ‘Will it rain today?’,” one 65-year-old olive farmer told me. “It used to snow waist-deep, and roads would remain closed for weeks. Today, children have forgotten what snow is.” 

    Agricultural stress isn’t limited to Iznik. In 2025, Türkiye’s crop and field production fell by 9%, while fruits, beverage and spice plants lost nearly a third of their output. According to the agriculture ministry, drought and frost were the main causes.

    Visible scars of climate crisis

    Sinkholes are also rapidly increasing, now numbering more than 1,000. Most of them are located in the Konya Basin, where groundwater levels fall by about 2 metres a year due to reduced rainfall and excessive extraction. 

    Türkiye’s sinkholes aren’t just a hazard to human life and infrastructure. They’re a graphic representation of how two human-made phenomena – groundwater exploitation and the climate crisis – combine to weaken the land, causing it to collapse upon itself.  

    Burnt forests, disappearing lakes, gaping sinkholes: many of these reminders of the climate crisis will remain hidden from visitors in Antalya this month. But the clamour for action will be on full display.

    People ride a motorcycle past a damaged building in the aftermath of a wildfire in Guzelyali, Canakkale, Turkey, August 12, 2025. REUTERS/Dilara Senkaya

    People ride a motorcycle past a damaged building in the aftermath of a wildfire in Guzelyali, Canakkale, Turkey, August 12, 2025. REUTERS/Dilara Senkaya

    Since last year’s climate summit, a growing number of countries have rallied around a way forward: roadmaps to transition away from fossil fuels. More than just emission-reduction targets, these transition roadmaps are concrete plans on how to end dependence on fossil fuels, the main driver of climate change, in a just and orderly way. 

    As the Hormuz crisis has shown, not having to rely on oil and gas is no longer just about saving future generations from climate catastrophe – it’s also about saving next month’s household budget. 

    Electrification milestone

    Türkiye is highly dependent on imported fossil fuels, spending an average of $42 billion annually on oil, gas, and coal over the last 10 years. The Hormuz crisis has increased these costs, with Turkish households and businesses losing an additional $3 billion in just two months’ worth of fossil fuel price spikes.

    In launching the “35 by 35” electrification target, Türkiye’s COP President Murat Kurum acknowledged the need to protect citizens from high energy prices. This new global target for electricity to meet 35% of final energy demand by 2035 is shaping up to be one of the milestones of this year’s climate talks. 

    It’s a good target because electrifying transport, buildings and industry significantly cuts not just pollution, but daily expenses too. But electrification alone is not enough. Without an accompanying fossil fuel phase-out, electrification won’t be able to stop further climate and economic catastrophe.

    Comment: Turkey must make COP31 a turning point for global climate action

    A case in point is Türkiye’s new National Energy Plan 2040. The plan’s emphasis on electrification and the expansion of renewable energy capacity is welcome – these are positive steps that align with the messages coming from Türkiye’s COP31 presidency. However, for the plan to represent genuinely ambitious climate action, it must include a clear commitment and timeline to phase out coal.

    Türkiye still relies on mostly imported coal for around one-third of its energy. A 350.org report has revealed that the coal trade between Türkiye and Australia – with which it shares the COP31 presidency – has been responsible for roughly 75 million tonnes of carbon emissions since the Paris Agreement was signed. Neither country has a coal phase-out date.

    COP31 is an opportunity to change course. The Turkish government has made good progress on expanding solar and wind energy. In 2025, Türkiye surpassed its solar target as capacity had more than doubled in recent years. It must now build on this progress.

    The world will be watching Türkiye as the climate summit heads into its second week. The Turkish government must ensure that global leaders implement real solutions that won’t leave its own citizens high and dry.

    The post Behind the COP31 fanfare, Türkiye is worried about water appeared first on Climate Home News.

    Behind the COP31 fanfare, Türkiye is worried about water

    Continue Reading

    Climate Change

    Scientists defend UN overshoot report after Saudi-led push to sideline it at COP31

    Published

    on

    Scientists behind a landmark UN report on overshooting the 1.5C warming limit have defended its credibility, after Saudi Arabia and other large developing countries questioned its scientific legitimacy and sought to keep it out of the main political decision expected from COP31.

    The UN Environment Programme’s (UNEP) Limiting Overshoot report, published in September, examines how to minimise an almost certain breach of the Paris Agreement’s temperature goal, what crossing it will mean for people and ecosystems and how temperatures could be brought back down.

    The European Union, the UK, the Least Developed Countries (LDCs) and small island states are among those pushing for COP31 to make the response to overshoot of 1.5C one of the summit’s priorities.

    But during closed-door consultations on the cover decision this week, the Arab Group, led by Saudi Arabia, have tried to cast doubt on the report’s scientific rigour, arguing it had not been peer-reviewed, according to sources familiar with the discussions.

    Meanwhile, the bloc of Like-Minded Developing Countries (LDMCs), which included India and China, called for the cover decision to avoid references to reports produced outside the UN climate process, seen by observers as a thinly-veiled reference to the UNEP report.

    Laurence Tubiana, CEO of the European Climate Foundation and one of the key architects of the Paris Agreement, said the overshoot report “tells us a truth some would rather hide”.

    “We are on course to exceed 1.5C and limiting how far and for how long is a matter of survival for us all,” she told Climate Home News. “The attacks on climate science are an attempt to delay action. They target intergovernmental institutions that give countries a shared scientific basis for acting together.”