Comedy and Tragedy (credit: Photo by Ilargian Faus)
Episode 92: There’s Something Funny about Climate Change
In this episode of Citizens’ Climate Radio, listeners hear stories, insights, and innovative approaches to tackling climate change. From the unique perspective of a climate change comedian who marries humor with serious environmental advocacy to the empowering tales of youth activism at the global COP28 summit, this episode showcases diverse methods of engagement and action. Highlighting the importance of resilience, space for mental and emotional health, and the groundbreaking work of package-free shopping, it will inspire you while providing you with practical guidance.
A Climate Change Comedian?
Brian Ettling shares his compelling journey from a park ranger to an influential climate change comedian, a story that encapsulates the essence of turning gloom into bloom. With seventeen years of experience as a seasonal ranger in the majestic landscapes of Crater Lake National Park and Everglades National Park, Brian shares how a simple yet profound question about global warming from a park visitor sparked a drastic shift in his career path and life purpose.
“Excuse me, all-knowing ranger,” a visitor said. “I have a question.” I smiled, humbly curious and certain I had the answer. “What’s happening with global warming in the Everglades?” Wait. What?! I knew nothing about global warming, and visitors hate when park rangers tell you, ‘I don’t know.’
Brian spent time researching the question and was shocked by what he discovered.
The information I learned scared me. What the (bleep)! Because of climate change, sea level was expected to rise at least three feet in Everglades National Park by the end of the 21st century. The sea would swallow up most of the park and nearby Miami since the highest point of the park road is less than three feet above sea level. UGH, I hate you, climate change!
This pivotal moment led him to deeply research climate change, eventually inspiring him to merge his passion for environmental advocacy with his unique sense of humor. An amateur video on YouTube led to two national television appearances on Comedy Central’s Tosh.0. Daniel Tosh introduced America to the goofball who became the Climate Change Comedian.
Brian’s narrative is a vivid testament to the power of individual transformation and the role of creativity in addressing serious global issues. He illustrates this by recounting defining moments in his journey, and he invites us to experience the journey complete with silly sound effects and a musical score.
Brian Ettling is a dynamic climate change communicator from Portland, Oregon, with a deep history of engagement with Citizens’ Climate Lobby (CCL). Over the years, he has worn multiple hats within CCL, including legislative liaison, co-chapter leader, and Missouri State co-coordinator. His dedication is evident in his attendance at nine CCL international conferences in Washington, D.C., where he served as a breakout speaker. Additionally, Brian has contributed his insights at the Canadian National CCL conference, showcasing his unwavering commitment to climate advocacy.
Listen Now!
Resilience Corner
Tamara Staton explores the nuanced relationship between space—both physical and emotional—and climate advocacy. Tamara emphasizes the importance of creating space for rest and reflection to enhance effectiveness in climate activism. She illustrates this with personal anecdotes, suggesting, “When I create space, I enable presence and perspective… Creating space widens our window of tolerance, allowing us to respond with grace, ease, and courage to the challenges we face.” She underscores the critical balance between passionate activism and the need for self-care to sustain long-term engagement in climate work.
Tamara Staton is the Education and Resilience Coordinator for Citizens’ Climate Education.
Get more tips and resources by visiting The Resilience Hub on CCL Community.
NEW! The CCL Youth Corner
The Citizens’ Climate Lobby Youth Corner introduces a vibrant platform where middle and high school students across the USA amplify their voices on climate action. Host Veda Ganesan highlights their proactive efforts to make their voices heard at COP28. She shares the important role CCL Youth volunteer Vinay Karthik played at the international conference in Dubai. In the next Youth Corner, you will learn about The Great School Electrification Challenge.
Dig Deeper: Check out the CCL Youth Blog.
Veda Ganesan is the producer and host of CCR’s new Citizens’ Climate Lobby Youth Corner; it is a project of CCL Youth. Veda also hosts Sustainable Cents podcast.
Good News
Damon Motz-Storey (they, them) shines a spotlight on the Realm Refillery in Portland, Oregon, a pioneering package-free grocery store. It exemplifies sustainable shopping by offering a wide variety of bulk goods, from flour to laundry detergent, all without disposable packaging, presenting a compelling model for reducing single-use plastics and living one’s environmental values.
Damon Motz-Storey is an active climate advocate and the Oregon Chapter Director of the Sierra Club, dedicated to promoting sustainable practices and environmental conservation.
In other Good News, Peterson Toscano highlights two innovative climate change exhibitions in New York City museums. At the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA), Life Cycles: The Materials of Contemporary Design showcases the intersection of design and sustainability, featuring Solar Ivy, a system of small solar panels resembling leaves that generate energy from sunlight and wind. Additionally, the Climate Museum in SOHO focuses entirely on climate change, currently featuring “The End of Fossil Fuel,” and encourages visitors to engage in actionable steps toward environmental advocacy.
If you have a Good News Story to share, contact us: Radio @ CitizensClimate.org
Take a Meaningful Next Step
Each month, we will suggest meaningful, achievable, and measurable next steps for you to consider. We recognize that action is an antidote to despair. If you need help with what you can do, consider one of the following next steps.
- If you are in middle or high school, visit CCLUSA.org/Youth to learn about their Great School Electrification Challenge!
- If you are a college student, you can get involved with CCL Higher Education and the College Carbon Fee and Dividend Movement. Learn how you can jumpstart a campaign on your campus.
- Sign up for monthly text reminders to contact your members of Congress and get the step-by-step guidance you need to reach lawmakers effectively. Visit CCLUSA.org/Action
Stay Tuned
In the March 2024 episode, you will meet Erica Valdez, the newest team member of Citizens’ Climate Radio. Erica, Horace, and Peterson will engage in a discussion on the various roles individuals can adopt in addressing climate change. Eileen Flannagan, a Quaker author, activist, and trainer, will elaborate on the four roles change-makers often play: Advocate, Rebel, Helper, and Organizer. They ask, “What is your role on this new planet???” The episode is set to premiere on Friday, March 22nd, 2024.
Listener Survey
We want to hear your feedback about this episode. After you listen, feel free to fill in this short survey. Your feedback will help us make new decisions about the content, guests, and style of the show. You can fill it out anonymously and answer whichever questions you like. You can also reach us by email: radio @citizensclimatelobby.org
You can hear Citizens’ Climate Radio on:
Also, feel free to connect with other listeners, suggest program ideas, and respond to programs in the Citizens’ Climate Radio Facebook group, on X (formerly known as Twitter) @CitizensCRadio, Instagram @CitizensClimateRadio, LinkedIn, or TikTok @ClimateChangePodcast
Read the Transcript
Episode 92
There’s Something Funny about Climate Change
SUMMARY KEYWORDS
climate, climate change, youth, space, ccl, comedian, park, years, Everglades National Park, climate action, park ranger,
SPEAKERS
Tamara Staton, Peterson Toscano, Veda Ganesan, Damon Motz-Storey, Horace Mo, Brian Ettling
Peterson Toscano 00:00
Welcome to Citizens’ Climate Radio, your climate change podcast. In the show, we highlight people’s stories we celebrate your successes, and together we share strategies for talking about climate change. I’m your host Peterson Toscano. Welcome to Episode 92 of Citizens’ Climate Radio project of Citizens’ Climate Education. This episode is airing on Friday, February 23 2024.
Peterson Toscano 00:29
We have an episode for you that is packed with helpful resources, good news and tools to help you in your climate work. Tamara Staton is back with the resilience corner. You will hear her make a connection between our climate work and space. (sound of space ship) No, not that kind of space. Tamara has something else in mind. We have a good news story about a store that has completely done away with any packaging. Damon Motz-Storey, the Oregon chapter director for the Sierra Club gives us a personal tour. We are thrilled to premiere a new recurring feature of our show., The Citizens’ Climate Lobby Youth Corner Veda Ganesan tells us about the critical role youth played at last year’s COP 28th meeting. At this global UN summit youth had a seat at the table, and they had a lot to say. I will tell you about two museums I recently visited in New York City. They both seek to inform and inspire the public about climate change.
Peterson Toscano 01:33
But we begin our show with a story. We all have our own climate change origin stories. Your concern over global warming may have just started in elementary school or middle school or high school or it happened in college or even later in your life. Our guest today is a man who got so shaken up about climate change, he needed to do something serious about it. His concerns were so serious that he turned to comedy to communicate his message. Brian Ettling and I collaborated to bring history to life with music and sound effects. Enjoy.
Brian Ettling 02:10
“How would you like to have fun and make a difference in the climate movement? Travel with me through time and space to Ashland Oregon in 2009. (Harp sound fades into pop music from the 2000s) I was house-sitting for a friend and unsure what to do with my life. My friend Naomi pressed me to answer her directly: ‘What do you want to do with your life???’ ‘Fine!’ I said, ‘If I could be anything, I would like to be the “Climate Change Comedian”!’ Naomi fell out of her chair laughing. (Object hitting floor sound) She said: ‘That’s great! NowI go straight home and start a website with that name right now!’ I did and started building the website, climatechangecomedian.com (typing on a computer keyboard sound).
Brian Ettling 02:10
By 2009, I had worked for seventeen years as a seasonal park ranger at Crater Lake National Park, Oregon (a gentle sound of water sloshing) in the summers and Everglades National Park, Florida (A Limpkin bird call) in the winters. I loved every minute of standing in front of an audience giving ranger talks in these iconic places sharing about nature. Let’s go back further in time to 1998 (the sound of a harp like a dream sequence), See that’s me in that form fitting ranger’s uniform. I was so excited to start my first job as a ranger tour guide in the national parks. I had worked various jobs for six years in the national parks, but this would be my first time narrating boat tours and talking about the park to the public.
Brian Ettling 02:17
The nights before my first boat tour, I stayed up late studying. (paging flipping fast in a book) I schooled myself on the alligators, birds, dolphins, and manatees. I dug deep into the history of the park, along with Native American and settler stories. I prepared myself to be the all knowing ranger. (trumpets and possible echo announcement of THE ALL KNOWING RANGER!) Oh look, that’s me during one of my first boat tours. “Excuse me, all-knowing ranger,” a visitor said. “I have a question” I smiled humbly, curious, and certain I had the answer. “What’s happening with global warming in the Everglades?” Wait What?!? I knew nothing about global warming (Whomp Whomp sound). And Visitors hate when park rangers tell you, “I don’t know.” This was before smartphones, so I hopped off the boatI (splash) then ran to the park library (put in the sound of a house clip-clopping. and I interject “No me running on foot.” then I put in another one but through water and you say, “I am not running in the swamp!” then I do normal running.) and the nearest Miami bookstore (car in a hurry sound with tires screeching) to read allI the scientific books I could find on climate change.
Brian Ettling 05:00
The information I learned scared me. (somber music) (gasp) What the (bleep). (sound of pages turning) (‘Because of climate change, sea level was expected to rise at least three feet in Everglades National Park by the end of the 21st century. The sea would swallow up most of the park and nearby Miami since the highest point of the park road is less than three feet above sea level.’ What about the crocodiles, alligators, and beautiful Flamingos! What about all of this ideal coastal habitat will be lost because of sea level rinse. UGH I hate you climate change! “Ok enough with being back in the Everglades in 1998 (harp music to signify time travel.) So, what did I do next? I was so worried about climate change, I quit my job in Everglades National Park. That was after 10 years as a park ranger. I moved back to my hometown of St. Louis, Missouri. I had to do something about climate change… In 2014, the lightbulb went on: ‘Hey I am the Climate Change Comedian! (echo echo echo) I created a YouTube video that year., I enlisted my mom, Fran Ettling, who plays the piano. I titled, the video “Climate Change Comedian and the Pianist!” (An audio clip from the YouTube video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_7KGU8LHQQ)
Brian Ettling 06:32
Me: “I am so proud that my mom is such a talented organist and piano player.” Fran Ettling “I’m so proud of Brian. He’s always eaten his vegetables.” Me: “As you can tell, my mom plays beautiful piano music. And I think I am very funny. Fran Ettling: “You are not that funny.”) And like everyone who posts a random, homemade video on YouTube, I became a star! Well kinda sorta. It was April 2016, and A producer of Comedy Central’s TV show Tosh.o noticed the video and called me to say: “We want to fly your mom and you to Los Angeles for a videotaped interview with host Daniel Tosh that will later air on TV.” (sound of an airplane flying by) The TV show aired nationally on the Comedy Channel on August 2, 2016.
Brian Ettling 07:53
Daniel Tosh: “MY FIRST GUEST IS AMERICA’S FAVORITE AND ONLY CLIMATE CHANGE COMEDIAN. HERE TO ENTERTAIN AND INFORM US, BRIAN.” Me: GREAT TO BE HERE, DANNITY.) To this day, appearing on Comedy Central’s Tosh.o was one of the highlights of my life. I talked about climate change using humor on national TV. It was seen by millions of people. I reached my dream! First as a park ranger and at last a Climate Change Comedian In fact, in 12 years I gave over 200 climate change talks in 12 U.S. states, Plus DC and Ottawa Canada. Tosh.o even brought me back as a guest a few years later. (sound of applause, cheering crowd, Trumpets sounding)
Brian Ettling 09:14
Then 2020 (pandemic music–trust me I have a whole catalog) OK we don’t have to travel back in time to the Covid Pandemic. It was a heavy time for all of us. I stopped doing Climate change comedy. For two years, “I felt lost and even angry. I lost my mojo.” But then (Austin Powers type music) I got a phone call from Robin Riddlebarger, Park Superintendent of Hanging Rock State Park, North Carolina. She left a message in May 2022. (sound of a phone answering machine) (female voice mail) “Howdy Brian! Stumbled upon your Climate Change Comedian website as I was searching for inspiration about a guest for our annual conference of superintendents for North Carolina State Parks. I am organizing this year’s conference.…We want this conference to be inspiring and refreshing instead of depressing like it usually is. I’d love to find out (if you could give) an in-person presentation to a bunch of crusty park superintendents.” I immediately jumped on this opportunity and called Robin back. I asked why they were interested in me as a speaker. Me?? Why me?
Brian Ettling 10:29
(female voice) Myself and three other superintendents are brainstorming guest speakers that will inspire us. We found we usually leave the conference feeling more burnt out than we were when we arrived. We are determined this year will be different. We will at least learn something. Instead of listening to boring HR policies that could have been handled in an email.’ As a professional speaker and former park ranger, this was a perfect fit for me. I spent the next five months preparing this talk. (typing and papers shuttling sound) I flew to North Carolina to speak in November of 2022. (sound of wings flapping, “No, in an airplane!” Sound of an airplane flying by)
Brian Ettling 11:13
“Hey folks, it’s great to be here in North Carolina. You know, when Robin reached out to me, she said he wanted something exciting instead of listening to boring HR policies that could have been handled in an email.” (sound of laughter) It felt like I got mojo (disco party music) back with this talk. (the sound of Ta-Da!) Since then I have begun traveling to other states to give educational, entertaining, and inspiring climate change talks. AND I get to be funny, which is not at all what people expect from a climate presentation. (gentle fun music) Thanks so much for listening to my story. And what about you? Do you feel like a climate action figure who is lost in the toy box? I am here to say there is a role for you! If I can have fun pursuing my dream to save the planet as the ‘Climate Change Comedian,’ I have no doubt you can pursue yours too! Oh I have to dash to my next climate comedy gig (sound of locomotive) “No not by train (Sound of plane) No not a plane. (sound of old car) No, silly, I will ride my bike (sounds of bike bell, gears, etc)
Peterson Toscano 12:40
Thank you so much, Brian. Brian Ettling lives in Portland, Oregon, and has a long, rich history with Citizens’ Climate Lobby. His involvement with CCL began 14 years ago. Since that time, he has served in various roles, including as a legislative liaison co chapter leader and the Missouri State co coordinator has attended nine CCL international conferences in Washington DC and has spoken as a breakout speaker there for different times, is even presented at the Canadian National CCL conference. Brian is a tireless advocate. Thank you, Brian, for all you do. Follow Brian on x at Brian ethylene and visit his website. That site is climate change. comedian.com I would love to hear your climate story and maybe even share it in a future episode. You can reach me by email, email us radio at citizens climate.org That’s radio at citizens climate.org Now it is time for the resilience corner with Tamara Staton.
Tamara Staton 13:51
Hi, I’m Tamara Staton, CCLs education and resilience coordinator and this is resilient climate tearing through unexpected Climate Connections. This isn’t a series out weather or science or graphs or data, though I might reference a few of those from time to time. Instead, it’s a series about things that help us worry less and act more on climate explored through a lens of playful curiosity. Together, we’ll explore how to enjoy what matters so deeply so that we can be as effective as possible for as long as we’re needed. Today’s topic is space and climate.
Tamara Staton 14:28
These two seemingly unrelated concepts actually relate to one another in quite a few interesting ways, space and climate. First of all, for many of us, climate change takes up a lot of space, mental space, emotional space, and for many people and creatures on earth. Global warming drastically changes the amount and type of space that they can inhabit and enjoy. But let’s look at a more intriguing relationship between space and climate. Not surprisingly, many of us Feeling urgency around climate change. And with this urgency comes a drive to work hard, constantly, without rest. To work without space, we may lack the necessary space between actions, space between thoughts, space between words, weeks, and even the feelings we experience. I don’t know about you, but it’s really obvious when I need space or rest. Consider when you feel tired or overwhelmed or burned out or stressed out. Sometimes I don’t even know the source of my stress. There are so many things in life that might be the source. I might not even see the connection between stressful feelings and foundational concerns about climate. Or perhaps I do recognize the connection. And that can make it even harder to slow down and take some space because let’s face it, there are actions to be taken letters to be written calls to be made. There’s no time for taking space Tamara. But when I do take space. When I do allow for time and rest between my actions, between my weeks between my thoughts and feelings, I am actually a much more effective advocate.
Tamara Staton 16:14
When I create space, I enable presence and perspective. The space allows me to appreciate who I am and what I have. The space may well help you to connect more deeply to the community around you. space allows us to see things with more distance, which often changes our perspective. Creating space widens our window of tolerance. This then allows us to respond more often with grace, ease and courage to the challenges we face in the world. What might space look like for you? For me, it looks like putting my phone down and being present with my family. I can then listen intently as my daughter shares about her day. Creating space happens when I carve out times in my day and week when I don’t work on or even think about climate change. I’ve also been enjoying long walks to our local park on these walks. I listen to the birds and the wind instead of podcasts or music. Allowing space for my own thoughts to wander. Maybe for you, it’s a matter of going to bed earlier or sleeping later. Or picking up that meditation practice that you’ve been thinking about trying out. I encourage you to consider how you can make space so that you have time to recover, refresh and revive in between the vital climate action that you are doing.
Tamara Staton 17:43
In our next episode, I’ll dive into another set of Unexpected Climate Connections, puppies and climate. How do these fluffy rambunctious creatures have anything to do with our warming world? I’m Tamara Statan with the resilience corner. I thank you for listening and for your commitment to progress. To learn more about tools, trainings and resources for staying strong, through the climate challenge, check out our resilience hub at CCL usa.org/resilience. And until next month. Remember this. Find your passion. Let it guide you and you’ll do amazing things for our world.
Peterson Toscano 18:29
Thank you Tamara. The resilience corner is made possible through a collaboration with Tamara Staton education and resilience coordinator for Citizens’ Climate Education. The resiliency Hub website is CCL usa.org/resilience.
Peterson Toscano 18:48
And now for something brand new! (bold music)
We premiere a semi-regular feature to our show: The Youth Corner. Middle school students and high schoolers from around the USA created Citizens’ Climate Lobby Youth. They meet regularly online to discuss way to reach their peers the adults in their lives. They also are in the forefront of a campaign to electrify schools. And now, they are broadcasting their message on Citizens’ Climate Radio. Veda Ganesan is the producer and host of the CCL Youth Corner. Take it away Veda.
Veda Ganesan 19:25
[Podcast Intro] Episode One Veda: Welcome to Citizen Climate Radio’s Youth Corner! We will delve into the latest developments in climate action and environmental issues, all from the youth’s point of view. I’m Veda Ganesan, CCL national youth podcast lead. Today we’re bringing you a special episode focusing on COP28. What do young people think about the twenty-eighth United Nations Climate Summit? What made this COP different from previous ones? And what about all those oil companies taking part in this international climate conference?? Oh yeah, and I will tell you how CCL and a CCL youth volunteer, played a major role! [Transition music]
Veda Ganesan 20:07
Veda: COP28 in Dubai recently made headlines. I am fascinated by the scale of it all. Get this – a remarkable 84,000 attendees, more than double the previous record-holder COP26. One thing that truly caught my attention was the deliberate effort to create a more inclusive dialogue. It wasn’t just about negotiations at the table; there were also various side events spread across the two-week conference. This definitely added a whole new depth of experience.
Veda Ganesan 20:32
Point 1: Youth Engagement Veda: On the home front, our own CCL youth volunteer, Vinay Karthik, was selected to join the Global Coordination Team (GCT) for YOUNGO. This is the youth constituency of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Comprising approximately 40 leaders from around the globe, the GCT plays a crucial role in organizing UN climate conventions, conferences, and events. Among the 15 youth selected worldwide, Vinay was appointed to the Communications and Media Team. Serving as the Logistics Manager for COP28 in Dubai, he represented the mainland United States in this significant role. Vinay got to take part in the introduction of the inaugural Youth Climate Champion. It’s a ministerial-level role aimed at fostering connections between governments, officials, and young climate activists. This program fully financed the engagement of one hundred young individuals from different corners of the globe, empowering them to actively participate in the negotiations.
Ah, but don’t imagine that all these youth sat quietly at the kid’s table. Let me spill the tea on what went down at COP28’s Youth, Children, Education, and Skills Day. So we have the Youth Stocktake, breaking ground and shaking up the climate scene. They’re on a mission to figure out just how much we, the youth, are rocking the climate negotiation boat. Countries got in on the action, making serious moves to crank up our volume in the discussions. It’s all about giving the ones most hit by climate change a real say, right alongside the experts. Keep your ears peeled for the real deal on this event—it’s all about paving the way for a greener future!
Veda Ganesan 21:48
Point 2: Gender Equality Veda: Guess what was buzzing at COP28? A whole day just for gender equality! They brought in big shots, made bold promises, all geared up for gender-friendly moves. They shone a light on the real deal – the challenges women and girls face in the climate hustle. Whether it was the big guns or small talks, they zoned in on fixing the gender balance. And guess what? Would you believe me if I told you only about a third of the country negotiating teams represented by women?? Time to shake things up for a climate game where everyone’s got a fair shot!
Veda Ganesan 22:04
Point 3: Corporate Presence and Perspectives Veda: With word from Vinay, the inclusivity extended to various stakeholders, including more than 1,300 affiliates of fossil fuel companies. Interestingly, representatives from major oil and gas corporations such as Shell, Chevron, TotalEnergies, and BP attended, sparking discussions on their role in the climate dialogue. Can’t have a debate without the pro and con! Some attendees defended their inclusion, highlighting the potential for meaningful change if these companies are engaged in the conversation.
Veda Ganesan 22:15
Point 4: Diverse Perspectives and Challenges Veda: COP28 swung open the doors for all kinds of voices – youth, women, indigenous peeps, even corporate bigwigs. The goal? Stir up some positive vibes. But here’s the plot twist: Is this just talk, or are we really giving the spotlight to those who usually get left in the shadows?
Veda Ganesan 22:21
Closing Veda: As we wrap up our first feature on Citizens’ Climate Radio, it’s clear that COP28 aimed for a groundbreaking conference with inclusivity at its core. The challenge now is ensuring that the commitments declared at the event materialize into meaningful actions and bring about lasting change. We will report more on this in future episodes! So that concludes our time with you! Thank you for joining us for the CCL Youth Corner and stay tuned for our next episode on the Great Electrification Challenge, one of my favorites! To learn more about CCL Youth, visit CCLUSA.org slash Youth. [outro music]
Peterson Toscano 23:07
Thank you Veda! That was Veda Ganesan with a message from CCL Youth. Veda is host of the podcast Sustainable Cents. It is available wherever you get podcasts. If you are in middle school or high school, find out how you can get involved. Visit cclusa.org/youth that’s cclusa.org/youth. There you will also find out about the Great School Electrification Challenge! Our Good News Story today comes from Portland, Oregon. I visited the city last summer. In addition to meeting up with Tamara Staton and Brian Ettling, I also connected with Damon Motz-Storey. Damon is the Director of the Oregon Chapter of the Sierra Club. Damon took me to an extraordinary shop.
Damon Motz-Storey 24:07
We’re in Portland, Oregon, right now on northeast Broadway Street. And we’re just outside of this really cool little store called the Realm Refillery. It calls itself a package-free grocery. So I just wanted to point it out as a really cool spot here. That’s sort of a beacon and an example of what sustainable shopping can look like.
Peterson Toscano 24:27
And when you walk in, what do you see what will you experience?
Damon Motz-Storey 24:31
It’s so cute in there. There’s all these different glass jars and just the whole place has a very, like, warm and inviting feel. There’s plants that have been well curated throughout the establishment. And you as you look around, you start to realize like wow, they’ve got a lot of different kinds of things in here. They don’t just have like bulk goods like flowers and gluten free flowers. It’s Portland Come on, but they also have laundry detergent and all sorts of other supplies that you might need for going on a grocery shopping trip where You don’t buy any disposable packaging.
Damon Motz-Storey 25:04
So this is maybe a little more expensive than going to a Safeway or something like that. But it is so much higher quality and it is such a great way to really live your values and really say to other, you know, groceries and supermarkets like this is how it can be right this is this could be a way that we move away from all that single use plastic and so it’s like a little bit more costly, but it’s really worth it.
Peterson Toscano 25:40
Thank you, Damon. Visit Realm Refillery in Portland, Oregon at 2310 Northeast Broadway or visit online at therealmrefillery.com Learn more about Damon Motz-Storey and the Oregon chapter of the Sierra Club. Visit sierraclub.org/oregon.
Peterson Toscano 26:00
If you have good news you want to share on the show, I want to know about it. Email us. Radio @ CitizensClimatel.org. That Radio @Citizens’ Climate.org
Peterson Toscano 26:08
In the category of Good News, I want to mention two museums I recently visited in New York City. The Museum of Modern Art has a free exhibit on display. “Life Cycles: The Materials of Contemporary Design” is FREE and located on the first floor. The exhibit uncovers the dynamic intersection of design and sustainability. It pushes the boundaries towards eco-friendly innovation. The collection of art and design pieces helps us to reimagine creativity in a way that aligns with environmental values. My favorite piece is the Solar Ivy, also known as SMIT Grow. This is a fantastic system of small moving solar panels that look like leaves. They make energy from the sun, and when the wind blows, they create even more energy. These panels can be put on the side of buildings to create power. Solar Ivy is produced by a company in Brooklyn called SMIT. Each leaf has a special layer and a tiny generator that makes electricity when it’s sunny or windy.
Peterson Toscano 27:36
The exhibit is “Life Cycles: The Materials of Contemporary Design. Visit it for FREE at the Museum of Modern Art in New York City. If you cannot visit the exhibit yourself, you can see images online. I put links in the show notes for you.
Peterson Toscano 27:51
While in New York, I also popped into the Climate Museum. It is located in SOHO’s gallery district at 105 Wooster Street. The entire museum is dedicated to addressing the causes and impact of climate change. Their current exhibit, The End of Fossil Fuel, is on display until April 28, 2024. What I most appreciate about the museum is that it offer visitors the opportunity to take meaningful, measurable, and achievable action steps. This includes a station where you can write your member of congress. Learn more about the Climate Museum by visiting climatemuseum.org/
Peterson Toscano 28:30
Before we end this episode, we want you to get excited about next month’s show. To tell us about it is CCR team member Horace Mo
.
Horace Mo 28:54
Thanks, Peterson. Next month you will meet our newest team member, Erica Valdez. Erica will join Peterson and me for a conversation about the different parts we can play when addressing climate change. Eileen Flannagan, an activist and trainer, will tell us about four different roles change-makers often play in change movements. These are Advocate, Rebel, Helper, and Organizer. What is your part to play in our rapidly changing world? Learn how to be an even more effective climate action figure. The episode will premiere on Friday March 22nd, 2024.
Peterson Toscano 29:38
Thank you Horace, and Thank you for joining me for Episode 92 of Citizens’ Climate Radio.
Peterson Toscano 29:40
If you like what you hear and you want to support the work we do, visit CitizensClimateEducation.org. There, you can make a tax-deductible contribution. That website is CitizensClimateEducation.org We want you to be effective in the climate work you do. Citizens’ Climate Education provides training, local group meetings, and many resources. We help you build the confidence and skills you need to pursue and promote climate solutions. Find out how you can learn, grow, and connect with others who are engaged in meaningful work. Visit CCLusa.org, that’s CCLusa.org.
Peterson Toscano 29:50
Do you have your feedback about this episode? After you listen, feel free to fill out a short survey. You will find a link to the survey in our show notes over at cclusa.org/radio or just email me, radio @ citizensclimate.org Citizens’ Climate Radio is written and produced by me—Peterson Toscano, along with the CCR Team: Horace Mo and Erica Valdez. Special thanks to Veda Genesan, Tamara Staton, Brian Ettling, and Damon Motz-Story for their contributions to this episode. Technical come support from Ricky Bradley and Brett Cease. Social media assistance from Flannery Winchester and Moral support from Madeline Para. The music on today’s show comes from Epidemicsound.com.
Peterson Toscano 30:25
Please share Citizens’ Climate Radio with your friends and colleagues. You can find Citizens’ Climate Radio wherever you listen to podcasts. You can also listen at NortherSpiritradio.org You can now follow us on Twitter, Instagram, LinkedIn, Facebook and Tiktok. Feel free to leave a voicemail at our listener phone live (619) 512-9646. +1 if calling from outside the USA that number again. (619) 512-9646. Visit cclusa.org/radio to see our show notes, a full transcript of the episode, links to our guests, and much more. Citizens’ Climate Radio is a project of Citizens’ Climate Education.
The post Episode 92: There’s Something Funny about Climate Change appeared first on Citizens' Climate Lobby.
Greenhouse Gases
Heatwaves driving recent ‘surge’ in compound drought and heat extremes
Drought and heatwaves occurring together – known as “compound” events – have “surged” across the world since the early 2000s, a new study shows.
Compound drought and heat events (CDHEs) can have devastating effects, creating the ideal conditions for intense wildfires, such as Australia’s “Black Summer” of 2019-20 where bushfires burned 24m hectares and killed 33 people.
The research, published in Science Advances, finds that the increase in CDHEs is predominantly being driven by events that start with a heatwave.
The global area affected by such “heatwave-led” compound events has more than doubled between 1980-2001 and 2002-23, the study says.
The rapid increase in these events over the last 23 years cannot be explained solely by global warming, the authors note.
Since the late 1990s, feedbacks between the land and the atmosphere have become stronger, making heatwaves more likely to trigger drought conditions, they explain.
One of the study authors tells Carbon Brief that societies must pay greater attention to compound events, which can “cause severe impacts on ecosystems, agriculture and society”.
Compound events
CDHEs are extreme weather events where drought and heatwave conditions occur simultaneously – or shortly after each other – in the same region.
These events are often triggered by large-scale weather patterns, such as “blocking” highs, which can produce “prolonged” hot and dry conditions, according to the study.
Prof Sang-Wook Yeh is one of the study authors and a professor at the Ewha Womans University in South Korea. He tells Carbon Brief:
“When heatwaves and droughts occur together, the two hazards reinforce each other through land-atmosphere interactions. This amplifies surface heating and soil moisture deficits, making compound events more intense and damaging than single hazards.”
CDHEs can begin with either a heatwave or a drought.
The sequence of these extremes is important, the study says, as they have different drivers and impacts.
For example, in a CDHE where the heatwave was the precursor, increased direct sunshine causes more moisture loss from soils and plants, leading to a drought.
Conversely, in an event where the drought was the precursor, the lack of soil moisture means that less of the sun’s energy goes into evaporation and more goes into warming the Earth’s surface. This produces favourable conditions for heatwaves.
The study shows that the majority of CDHEs globally start out as a drought.
In recent years, there has been increasing focus on these events due to the devastating impact they have on agriculture, ecosystems and public health.
In Russia in the summer of 2010, a compound drought-heatwave event – and the associated wildfires – caused the death of nearly 55,000 people, the study notes.

The record-breaking Pacific north-west “heat dome” in 2021 triggered extreme drought conditions that caused “significant declines” in wheat yields, as well as in barley, canola and fruit production in British Columbia and Alberta, Canada, says the study.
Increasing events
To assess how CDHEs are changing, the researchers use daily reanalysis data to identify droughts and heatwaves events. (Reanalysis data combines past observations with climate models to create a historical climate record.) Then, using an algorithm, they analyse how these events overlap in both time and space.
The study covers the period from 1980 to 2023 and the world’s land surface, excluding polar regions where CDHEs are rare.
The research finds that the area of land affected by CDHEs has “increased substantially” since the early 2000s.
Heatwave-led events have been the main contributor to this increase, the study says, with their spatial extent rising 110% between 1980-2001 and 2002-23, compared to a 59% increase for drought-led events.
The map below shows the global distribution of CDHEs over 1980-2023. The charts show the percentage of the land surface affected by a heatwave-led CDHE (red) or a drought-led CDHE (yellow) in a given year (left) and relative increase in each CDHE type (right).
The study finds that CDHEs have occurred most frequently in northern South America, the southern US, eastern Europe, central Africa and south Asia.

Threshold passed
The authors explain that the increase in heatwave-led CDHEs is related to rising global temperatures, but that this does not tell the whole story.
In the earlier 22-year period of 1980-2001, the study finds that the spatial extent of heatwave-led CDHEs rises by 1.6% per 1C of global temperature rise. For the more-recent period of 2022-23, this increases “nearly eightfold” to 13.1%.
The change suggests that the rapid increase in the heatwave-led CDHEs occurred after the global average temperature “surpasse[d] a certain temperature threshold”, the paper says.
This threshold is an absolute global average temperature of 14.3C, the authors estimate (based on an 11-year average), which the world passed around the year 2000.
Investigating the recent surge in heatwave-leading CDHEs further, the researchers find a “regime shift” in land-atmosphere dynamics “toward a persistently intensified state after the late 1990s”.
In other words, the way that drier soils drive higher surface temperatures, and vice versa, is becoming stronger, resulting in more heatwave-led compound events.
Daily data
The research has some advantages over other previous studies, Yeh says. For instance, the new work uses daily estimations of CDHEs, compared to monthly data used in past research. This is “important for capturing the detailed occurrence” of these events, says Yeh.
He adds that another advantage of their study is that it distinguishes the sequence of droughts and heatwaves, which allows them to “better understand the differences” in the characteristics of CDHEs.
Dr Meryem Tanarhte is a climate scientist at the University Hassan II in Morocco, and Dr Ruth Cerezo Mota is a climatologist and a researcher at the National Autonomous University of Mexico. Both scientists, who were not involved in the study, agree that the daily estimations give a clearer picture of how CDHEs are changing.
Cerezo-Mota adds that another major contribution of the study is its global focus. She tells Carbon Brief that in some regions, such as Mexico and Africa, there is a lack of studies on CDHEs:
“Not because the events do not occur, but perhaps because [these regions] do not have all the data or the expertise to do so.”
However, she notes that the reanalysis data used by the study does have limitations with how it represents rainfall in some parts of the world.
Compound impacts
The study notes that if CDHEs continue to intensify – particularly events where heatwaves are the precursors – they could drive declining crop productivity, increased wildfire frequency and severe public health crises.
These impacts could be “much more rapid and severe as global warming continues”, Yeh tells Carbon Brief.
Tanarhte notes that these events can be forecasted up to 10 days ahead in many regions. Furthermore, she says, the strongest impacts can be prevented “through preparedness and adaptation”, including through “water management for agriculture, heatwave mitigation measures and wildfire mitigation”.
The study recommends reassessing current risk management strategies for these compound events. It also suggests incorporating the sequences of drought and heatwaves into compound event analysis frameworks “to enhance climate risk management”.
Cerezo-Mota says that it is clear that the world needs to be prepared for the increased occurrence of these events. She tells Carbon Brief:
“These [risk assessments and strategies] need to be carried out at the local level to understand the complexities of each region.”
The post Heatwaves driving recent ‘surge’ in compound drought and heat extremes appeared first on Carbon Brief.
Heatwaves driving recent ‘surge’ in compound drought and heat extremes
Greenhouse Gases
DeBriefed 6 March 2026: Iran energy crisis | China climate plan | Bristol’s ‘pioneering’ wind turbine
Welcome to Carbon Brief’s DeBriefed.
An essential guide to the week’s key developments relating to climate change.
This week
Energy crisis
ENERGY SPIKE: US-Israeli attacks on Iran and subsequent counterattacks across the Middle East have sent energy prices “soaring”, according to Reuters. The newswire reported that the region “accounts for just under a third of global oil production and almost a fifth of gas”. The Guardian noted that shipping traffic through the strait of Hormuz, which normally ferries 20% of the world’s oil, “all but ground to a halt”. The Financial Times reported that attacks by Iran on Middle East energy facilities – notably in Qatar – triggered the “biggest rise in gas prices since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine”.
‘RISK’ AND ‘BENEFITS’: Bloomberg reported on increases in diesel prices in Europe and the US, speculating that rising fuel costs could be “a risk for president Donald Trump”. US gas producers are “poised to benefit from the big disruption in global supply”, according to CNBC. Indian government sources told the Economic Times that Russia is prepared to “fulfil India’s energy demands”. China Daily quoted experts who said “China’s energy security remains fundamentally unshaken”, thanks to “emergency stockpiles and a wide array of import channels”.
‘ESSENTIAL’ RENEWABLES: Energy analysts said governments should cut their fossil-fuel reliance by investing in renewables, “rather than just seeking non-Gulf oil and gas suppliers”, reported Climate Home News. This message was echoed by UK business secretary Peter Kyle, who said “doubling down on renewables” was “essential” amid “regional instability”, according to the Daily Telegraph.
China’s climate plan
PEAK COAL?: China has set out its next “five-year plan” at the annual “two sessions” meeting of the National People’s Congress, including its climate strategy out to 2030, according to the Hong Kong-based South China Morning Post. The plan called for China to cut its carbon emissions per unit of gross domestic product (GDP) by 17% from 2026 to 2030, which “may allow for continued increase in emissions given the rate of GDP growth”, reported Reuters. The newswire added that the plan also had targets to reach peak coal in the next five years and replace 30m tonnes per year of coal with renewables.
ACTIVE YET PRUDENT: Bloomberg described the new plan as “cautious”, stating that it “frustrat[es] hopes for tighter policy that would drive the nation to peak carbon emissions well before president Xi Jinping’s 2030 deadline”. Carbon Brief has just published an in-depth analysis of the plan. China Daily reported that the strategy “highlights measures to promote the climate targets of peaking carbon dioxide emissions before 2030”, which China said it would work towards “actively yet prudently”.
Around the world
- EU RULES: The European Commission has proposed new “made in Europe” rules to support domestic low-carbon industries, “against fierce competition from China”, reported Agence France-Presse. Carbon Brief examined what it means for climate efforts.
- RECORD HEAT: The US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has said there is a 50-60% chance that the El Niño weather pattern could return this year, amplifying the effect of global warming and potentially driving temperatures to “record highs”, according to Euronews.
- FLAGSHIP FUND: The African Development Bank’s “flagship clean energy fund” plans to more than double its financing to $2.5bn for African renewables over the next two years, reported the Associated Press.
- NO WITHDRAWAL: Vanuatu has defied US efforts to force the Pacific-island nation to drop a UN draft resolution calling on the world to implement a landmark International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling on climate, according to the Guardian.
98
The number of nations that submitted their national reports on tackling nature loss to the UN on time – just half of the 196 countries that are part of the UN biodiversity treaty – according to analysis by Carbon Brief.
Latest climate research
- Sea levels are already “much higher than assumed” in most assessments of the threat posed by sea-level rise, due to “inadequate” modelling assumptions | Nature
- Accelerating human-caused global warming could see the Paris Agreement’s 1.5C limit crossed before 2030 | Geophysical Research Letters covered by Carbon Brief
- Future “super El Niño events” could “significantly lower” solar power generation due to a reduction in solar irradiance in key regions, such as California and east China | Communications Earth & Environment
(For more, see Carbon Brief’s in-depth daily summaries of the top climate news stories on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.)
Captured

UK greenhouse gas emissions in 2025 fell to 54% below 1990 levels, the baseline year for its legally binding climate goals, according to new Carbon Brief analysis. Over the same period, data from the World Bank shows that the UK’s economy has expanded by 95%, meaning that emissions have been decoupling from growth.
Spotlight
Bristol’s ‘pioneering’ community wind turbine
Following the recent launch of the UK government’s local power plan, Carbon Brief visits one of the country’s community-energy success stories.
The Lawrence Weston housing estate is set apart from the main city of Bristol, wedged between the tree-lined grounds of a stately home and a sprawl of warehouses and waste incinerators. It is one of the most deprived areas in the city.
Yet, just across the M5 motorway stands a structure that has brought the spoils of the energy transition directly to this historically forgotten estate – a 4.2 megawatt (MW) wind turbine.
The turbine is owned by local charity Ambition Lawrence Weston and all the profits from its electricity sales – around £100,000 a year – go to the community. In the UK’s local power plan, it was singled out by energy secretary Ed Miliband as a “pioneering” project.
‘Sustainable income’
On a recent visit to the estate by Carbon Brief, Ambition Lawrence Weston’s development manager, Mark Pepper, rattled off the story behind the wind turbine.
In 2012, Pepper and his team were approached by the Bristol Energy Cooperative with a chance to get a slice of the income from a new solar farm. They jumped at the opportunity.
“Austerity measures were kicking in at the time,” Pepper told Carbon Brief. “We needed to generate an income. Our own, sustainable income.”
With the solar farm proving to be a success, the team started to explore other opportunities. This began a decade-long process that saw them navigate the Conservative government’s “ban” on onshore wind, raise £5.5m in funding and, ultimately, erect the turbine in 2023.
Today, the turbine generates electricity equivalent to Lawrence Weston’s 3,000 households and will save 87,600 tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) over its lifetime.

‘Climate by stealth’
Ambition Lawrence Weston’s hub is at the heart of the estate and the list of activities on offer is seemingly endless: birthday parties, kickboxing, a library, woodworking, help with employment and even a pop-up veterinary clinic. All supported, Pepper said, with the help of a steady income from community-owned energy.
The centre itself is kitted out with solar panels, heat pumps and electric-vehicle charging points, making it a living advertisement for the net-zero transition. Pepper noted that the organisation has also helped people with energy costs amid surging global gas prices.
Gesturing to the England flags dangling limply on lamp posts visible from the kitchen window, he said:
“There’s a bit of resentment around immigration and scarcity of materials and provision, so we’re trying to do our bit around community cohesion.”
This includes supper clubs and an interfaith grand iftar during the Muslim holy month of Ramadan.
Anti-immigration sentiment in the UK has often gone hand-in-hand with opposition to climate action. Right-wing politicians and media outlets promote the idea that net-zero policies will cost people a lot of money – and these ideas have cut through with the public.
Pepper told Carbon Brief he is sympathetic to people’s worries about costs and stressed that community energy is the perfect way to win people over:
“I think the only way you can change that is if, instead of being passive consumers…communities are like us and they’re generating an income to offset that.”
From the outset, Pepper stressed that “we weren’t that concerned about climate because we had other, bigger pressures”, adding:
“But, in time, we’ve delivered climate by stealth.”
Watch, read, listen
OIL WATCH: The Guardian has published a “visual guide” with charts and videos showing how the “escalating Iran conflict is driving up oil and gas prices”.
MURDER IN HONDURAS: Ten years on from the murder of Indigenous environmental justice advocate Berta Cáceres, Drilled asked why Honduras is still so dangerous for environmental activists.
TALKING WEATHER: A new film, narrated by actor Michael Sheen and titled You Told Us To Talk About the Weather, aimed to promote conversation about climate change with a blend of “poetry, folk horror and climate storytelling”.
Coming up
- 8 March: Colombia parliamentary election
- 9-19 March: 31st Annual Session of the International Seabed Authority, Kingston, Jamaica
- 11 March: UN Environment Programme state of finance for nature 2026 report launch
Pick of the jobs
- London School of Economics and Political Science, fellow in the social science of sustainability | Salary: £43,277-£51,714. Location: London
- NORCAP, innovative climate finance expert | Salary: Unknown. Location: Kyiv, Ukraine
- WBHM, environmental reporter | Salary: $50,050-$81,330. Location: Birmingham, Alabama, US
- Climate Cabinet, data engineer | Salary: hourly rate of $60-$120 per hour. Location: Remote anywhere in the US
DeBriefed is edited by Daisy Dunne. Please send any tips or feedback to debriefed@carbonbrief.org.
This is an online version of Carbon Brief’s weekly DeBriefed email newsletter. Subscribe for free here.
The post DeBriefed 6 March 2026: Iran energy crisis | China climate plan | Bristol’s ‘pioneering’ wind turbine appeared first on Carbon Brief.
Greenhouse Gases
Q&A: What does China’s 15th ‘five-year plan’ mean for climate change?
China’s leadership has published a draft of its 15th five-year plan setting the strategic direction for the nation out to 2030, including support for clean energy and energy security.
The plan sets a target to cut China’s “carbon intensity” by 17% over the five years from 2026-30, but also changes the basis for calculating this key climate metric.
The plan continues to signal support for China’s clean-energy buildout and, in general, contains no major departures from the country’s current approach to the energy transition.
The government reaffirms support for several clean-energy industries, ranging from solar and electric vehicles (EVs) through to hydrogen and “new-energy” storage.
The plan also emphasises China’s willingness to steer climate governance and be seen as a provider of “global public goods”, in the form of affordable clean-energy technologies.
However, while the document says it will “promote the peaking” of coal and oil use, it does not set out a timeline and continues to call for the “clean and efficient” use of coal.
This shows that tensions remain between China’s climate goals and its focus on energy security, leading some analysts to raise concerns about its carbon-cutting ambition.
Below, Carbon Brief outlines the key climate change and energy aspects of the plan, including targets for carbon intensity, non-fossil energy and forestry.
Note: this article is based on a draft published on 5 March and will be updated if any significant changes are made in the final version of the plan, due to be released at the close next week of the “two sessions” meeting taking place in Beijing.
- What is China’s 15th five-year plan?
- What does the plan say about China’s climate action?
- What is China’s new CO2 intensity target?
- Does the plan encourage further clean-energy additions?
- What does the plan signal about coal?
- How will China approach global climate governance in the next five years?
- What else does the plan cover?
What is China’s 15th five-year plan?
Five-year plans are one of the most important documents in China’s political system.
Addressing everything from economic strategy to climate policy, they outline the planned direction for China’s socio-economic development in a five-year period. The 15th five-year plan covers 2026-30.
These plans include several “main goals”. These are largely quantitative indicators that are seen as particularly important to achieve and which provide a foundation for subsequent policies during the five-year period.
The table below outlines some of the key “main goals” from the draft 15th five-year plan.
| Category | Indicator | Indicator in 2025 | Target by 2030 | Cumulative target over 2026-2030 | Characteristic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Economic development | Gross domestic product (GDP) growth (%) | 5 | Maintained within a reasonable range and proposed annually as appropriate. | Anticipatory | |
| ‘Green and low-carbon | Reduction in CO2 emissions per unit of GDP (%) | 17.7 | 17 | Binding | |
| Share of non-fossil energy in total energy consumption (%) | 21.7 | 25 | Binding | ||
| Security guarantee | Comprehensive energy production capacity (100m tonnes of standard coal equivalent) |
51.3 | 58 | Binding |
Select list of targets highlighted in the “main goals” section of the draft 15th five-year plan. Source: Draft 15th five-year plan.
Since the 12th five-year plan, covering 2011-2015, these “main goals” have included energy intensity and carbon intensity as two of five key indicators for “green ecology”.
The previous five-year plan, which ran from 2021-2025, introduced the idea of an absolute “cap” on carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, although it did not provide an explicit figure in the document. This has been subsequently addressed by a policy on the “dual-control of carbon” issued in 2024.
The latest plan removes the energy-intensity goal and elevates the carbon-intensity goal, but does not set an absolute cap on emissions (see below).
It covers the years until 2030, before which China has pledged to peak its carbon emissions. (Analysis for Carbon Brief found that emissions have been “flat or falling” since March 2024.)
The plans are released at the two sessions, an annual gathering of the National People’s Congress (NPC) and the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC). This year, it runs from 4-12 March.
The plans are often relatively high-level, with subsequent topic-specific five-year plans providing more concrete policy guidance.
Policymakers at the National Energy Agency (NEA) have indicated that in the coming years they will release five sector-specific plans for 2026-2030, covering topics such as the “new energy system”, electricity and renewable energy.
There may also be specific five-year plans covering carbon emissions and environmental protection, as well as the coal and nuclear sectors, according to analysts.
Other documents published during the two sessions include an annual government work report, which outlines key targets and policies for the year ahead.
The gathering is attended by thousands of deputies – delegates from across central and local governments, as well as Chinese Communist party members, members of other political parties, academics, industry leaders and other prominent figures.
What does the plan say about China’s climate action?
Achieving China’s climate targets will remain a key driver of the country’s policies in the next five years, according to the draft 15th five-year plan.
It lists the “acceleration” of China’s energy transition as a “major achievement” in the 14th five-year plan period (2021-2025), noting especially how clean-power capacity had overtaken fossil fuels.
The draft says China will “actively and steadily advance and achieve carbon peaking”, with policymakers continuing to strike a balance between building a “green economy” and ensuring stability.
Climate and environment continues to receive its own chapter in the plan. However, the framing and content of this chapter has shifted subtly compared with previous editions, as shown in the table below. For example, unlike previous plans, the first section of this chapter focuses on China’s goal to peak emissions.
| 11th five-year plan (2006-2010) | 12th five-year plan (2011-2015) | 13th five-year plan (2016-2020) | 14th five-year plan (2021-2025) | 15th five-year plan (2026-2030) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chapter title | Part 6: Build a resource-efficient and environmentally-friendly society | Part 6: Green development, building a resource-efficient and environmentally friendly society | Part 10: Ecosystems and the environment | Part 11: Promote green development and facilitate the harmonious coexistence of people and nature | Part 13: Accelerating the comprehensive green transformation of economic and social development to build a beautiful China |
| Sections | Developing a circular economy | Actively respond to global climate change | Accelerate the development of functional zones | Improve the quality and stability of ecosystems | Actively and steadily advancing and achieving carbon peaking |
| Protecting and restoring natural ecosystems | Strengthen resource conservation and management | Promote economical and intensive resource use | Continue to improve environmental quality | Continuously improving environmental quality | |
| Strengthening environmental protection | Vigorously develop the circular economy | Step up comprehensive environmental governance | Accelerate the green transformation of the development model | Enhancing the diversity, stability, and sustainability of ecosystems | |
| Enhancing resource management | Strengthen environmental protection efforts | Intensify ecological conservation and restoration | Accelerating the formation of green production and lifestyles | ||
| Rational utilisation of marine and climate resources | Promoting ecological conservation and restoration | Respond to global climate change | |||
| Strengthen the development of water conservancy and disaster prevention and mitigation systems | Improve mechanisms for ensuring ecological security | ||||
| Develop green and environmentally-friendly industries |
Title and main sections of the climate and environment-focused chapters in the last five five-year plans. Source: China’s 11th, 12th, 13th, 14th and 15th five-year plans.
The climate and environment chapter in the latest plan calls for China to “balance [economic] development and emission reduction” and “ensure the timely achievement of carbon peak targets”.
Under the plan, China will “continue to pursue” its established direction and objectives on climate, Prof Li Zheng, dean of the Tsinghua University Institute of Climate Change and Sustainable Development (ICCSD), tells Carbon Brief.
What is China’s new CO2 intensity target?
In the lead-up to the release of the plan, analysts were keenly watching for signals around China’s adoption of a system for the “dual-control of carbon”.
This would combine the existing targets for carbon intensity – the CO2 emissions per unit of GDP – with a new cap on China’s total carbon emissions. This would mark a dramatic step for the country, which has never before set itself a binding cap on total emissions.
Policymakers had said last year that this framework would come into effect during the 15th five-year plan period, replacing the previous system for the “dual-control of energy”.
However, the draft 15th five-year plan does not offer further details on when or how both parts of the dual-control of carbon system will be implemented. Instead, it continues to focus on carbon intensity targets alone.
Looking back at the previous five-year plan period, the latest document says China had achieved a carbon-intensity reduction of 17.7%, just shy of its 18% goal.
This is in contrast with calculations by Lauri Myllyvirta, lead analyst at the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA), which had suggested that China had only cut its carbon intensity by 12% over the past five years.
At the time it was set in 2021, the 18% target had been seen as achievable, with analysts telling Carbon Brief that they expected China to realise reductions of 20% or more.
However, the government had fallen behind on meeting the target.
Last year, ecology and environment minister Huang Runqiu attributed this to the Covid-19 pandemic, extreme weather and trade tensions. He said that China, nevertheless, remained “broadly” on track to meet its 2030 international climate pledge of reducing carbon intensity by more than 65% from 2005 levels.
Myllyvirta tells Carbon Brief that the newly reported figure showing a carbon-intensity reduction of 17.7% is likely due to an “opportunistic” methodological revision. The new methodology now includes industrial process emissions – such as cement and chemicals – as well as the energy sector.
(This is not the first time China has redefined a target, with regulators changing the methodology for energy intensity in 2023.)
For the next five years, the plan sets a target to reduce carbon intensity by 17%, slightly below the previous goal.
However, the change in methodology means that this leaves space for China’s overall emissions to rise by “3-6% over the next five years”, says Myllyvirta. In contrast, he adds that the original methodology would have required a 2% fall in absolute carbon emissions by 2030.
The dashed lines in the chart below show China’s targets for reducing carbon intensity during the 12th, 13th, 14th and 15th five-year periods, while the bars show what was achieved under the old (dark blue) and new (light blue) methodology.

The carbon-intensity target is the “clearest signal of Beijing’s climate ambition”, says Li Shuo, director at the Asia Society Policy Institute’s (ASPI) China climate hub.
It also links directly to China’s international pledge – made in 2021 – to cut its carbon intensity to more than 65% below 2005 levels by 2030.
To meet this pledge under the original carbon-intensity methodology, China would have needed to set a target of a 23% reduction within the 15th five-year plan period. However, the country’s more recent 2035 international climate pledge, released last year, did not include a carbon-intensity target.
As such, ASPI’s Li interprets the carbon-intensity target in the draft 15th five-year plan as a “quiet recalibration” that signals “how difficult the original 2030 goal has become”.
Furthermore, the 15th five-year plan does not set an absolute emissions cap.
This leaves “significant ambiguity” over China’s climate plans, says campaign group 350 in a press statement reacting to the draft plan. It explains:
“The plan was widely expected to mark a clearer transition from carbon-intensity targets toward absolute emissions reductions…[but instead] leaves significant ambiguity about how China will translate record renewable deployment into sustained emissions cuts.”
Myllyvirta tells Carbon Brief that this represents a “continuation” of the government’s focus on scaling up clean-energy supply while avoiding setting “strong measurable emission targets”.
He says that he would still expect to see absolute caps being set for power and industrial sectors covered by China’s emissions trading scheme (ETS). In addition, he thinks that an overall absolute emissions cap may still be published later in the five-year period.
Despite the fact that it has yet to be fully implemented, the switch from dual-control of energy to dual-control of carbon represents a “major policy evolution”, Ma Jun, director of the Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs (IPE), tells Carbon Brief. He says that it will allow China to “provide more flexibility for renewable energy expansion while tightening the net on fossil-fuel reliance”.
Does the plan encourage further clean-energy additions?
“How quickly carbon intensity is reduced largely depends on how much renewable energy can be supplied,” says Yao Zhe, global policy advisor at Greenpeace East Asia, in a statement.
The five-year plan continues to call for China’s development of a “new energy system that is clean, low-carbon, safe and efficient” by 2030, with continued additions of “wind, solar, hydro and nuclear power”.
In line with China’s international pledge, it sets a target for raising the share of non-fossil energy in total energy consumption to 25% by 2030, up from just under 21.7% in 2025.
The development of “green factories” and “zero-carbon [industrial] parks” has been central to many local governments’ strategies for meeting the non-fossil energy target, according to industry news outlet BJX News. A call to build more of these zero-carbon industrial parks is listed in the five-year plan.
Prof Pan Jiahua, dean of Beijing University of Technology’s Institute of Ecological Civilization, tells Carbon Brief that expanding demand for clean energy through mechanisms such as “green factories” represents an increasingly “bottom-up” and “market-oriented” approach to the energy transition, which will leave “no place for fossil fuels”.
He adds that he is “very much sure that China’s zero-carbon process is being accelerated and fossil fuels are being driven out of the market”, pointing to the rapid adoption of EVs.
The plan says that China will aim to double “non-fossil energy” in 10 years – although it does not clarify whether this means their installed capacity or electricity generation, or what the exact starting year would be.
Research has shown that doubling wind and solar capacity in China between 2025-2035 would be “consistent” with aims to limit global warming to 2C.
While the language “certainly” pushes for greater additions of renewable energy, Yao tells Carbon Brief, it is too “opaque” to be a “direct indication” of the government’s plans for renewable additions.
She adds that “grid stability and healthy, orderly competition” is a higher priority for policymakers than guaranteeing a certain level of capacity additions.
China continues to place emphasis on the need for large-scale clean-energy “bases” and cross-regional power transmission.
The plan says China must develop “clean-energy bases…in the three northern regions” and “integrated hydro-wind-solar complexes” in south-west China.
It specifically encourages construction of “large-scale wind and solar” power bases in desert regions “primarily” for cross-regional power transmission, as well as “major hydropower” projects, including the Yarlung Tsangpo dam in Tibet.
As such, the country should construct “power-transmission corridors” with the capacity to send 420 gigawatts (GW) of electricity from clean-energy bases in western provinces to energy-hungry eastern provinces by 2030, the plan says.
State Grid, China’s largest grid operator, plans to install “another 15 ultra-high voltage [UHV] transmission lines” by 2030, reports Reuters, up from the 45 UHV lines built by last year.
Below are two maps illustrating the interlinkages between clean-energy bases in China in the 15th (top) and 14th (bottom) five-year plan periods.
The yellow dotted areas represent clean energy bases, while the arrows represent cross-regional power transmission. The blue wind-turbine icons represent offshore windfarms and the red cooling tower icons represent coastal nuclear plants.


The 15th five-year plan map shows a consistent approach to the 2021-2025 period. As well as power being transmitted from west to east, China plans for more power to be sent to southern provinces from clean-energy bases in the north-west, while clean-energy bases in the north-east supply China’s eastern coast.
It also maps out “mutual assistance” schemes for power grids in neighbouring provinces.
Offshore wind power should reach 100GW by 2030, while nuclear power should rise to 110GW, according to the plan.
What does the plan signal about coal?
The increased emphasis on grid infrastructure in the draft 15th five-year plan reflects growing concerns from energy planning officials around ensuring China’s energy supply.
Ren Yuzhi, director of the NEA’s development and planning department, wrote ahead of the plan’s release that the “continuous expansion” of China’s energy system has “dramatically increased its complexity”.
He said the NEA felt there was an “urgent need” to enhance the “secure and reliable” replacement of fossil-fuel power with new energy sources, as well as to ensure the system’s “ability to absorb them”.
Meanwhile, broader concerns around energy security have heightened calls for coal capacity to remain in the system as a “ballast stone”.
The plan continues to support the “clean and efficient utilisation of fossil fuels” and does not mention either a cap or peaking timeline for coal consumption.
Xi had previously told fellow world leaders that China would “strictly control” coal-fired power and phase down coal consumption in the 15th five-year plan period.
The “geopolitical situation is increasing energy security concerns” at all levels of government, said the Institute for Global Decarbonization Progress in a note responding to the draft plan, adding that this was creating “uncertainty over coal reduction”.
Ahead of its publication, there were questions around whether the plan would set a peaking deadline for oil and coal. An article posted by state news agency Xinhua last month, examining recommendations for the plan from top policymakers, stated that coal consumption would plateau from “around 2027”, while oil would peak “around 2026”.
However, the plan does not lay out exact years by which the two fossil fuels should peak, only saying that China will “promote the peaking of coal and oil consumption”.
There are similarly no mentions of phasing out coal in general, in line with existing policy.
Nevertheless, there is a heavy emphasis on retrofitting coal-fired power plants. The plan calls for the establishment of “demonstration projects” for coal-plant retrofitting, such as through co-firing with biomass or “green ammonia”.
Such retrofitting could incentivise lower utilisation of coal plants – and thus lower emissions – if they are used to flexibly meet peaks in demand and to cover gaps in clean-energy output, instead of providing a steady and significant share of generation.
The plan also calls for officials to “fully implement low-carbon retrofitting projects for coal-chemical industries”, which have been a notable source of emissions growth in the past year.
However, the coal-chemicals sector will likely remain a key source of demand for China’s coal mining industry, with coal-to-oil and coal-to-gas bases listed as a “key area” for enhancing the country’s “security capabilities”.
Meanwhile, coal-fired boilers and industrial kilns in the paper industry, food processing and textiles should be replaced with “clean” alternatives to the equivalent of 30m tonnes of coal consumption per year, it says.
“China continues to scale up clean energy at an extraordinary pace, but the plan still avoids committing to strong measurable constraints on emissions or fossil fuel use”, says Joseph Dellatte, head of energy and climate studies at the Institut Montaigne. He adds:
“The logic remains supply-driven: deploy massive amounts of clean energy and assume emissions will eventually decline.”
How will China approach global climate governance in the next five years?
Meanwhile, clean-energy technologies continue to play a role in upgrading China’s economy, with several “new energy” sectors listed as key to its industrial policy.
Named sectors include smart EVs, “new solar cells”, new-energy storage, hydrogen and nuclear fusion energy.
“China’s clean-technology development – rather than traditional administrative climate controls – is increasingly becoming the primary driver of emissions reduction,” says ASPI’s Li. He adds that strengthening China’s clean-energy sectors means “more closely aligning Beijing’s economic ambitions with its climate objectives”.
Analysis for Carbon Brief shows that clean energy drove more than a third of China’s GDP growth in 2025, representing around 11% of China’s whole economy.
The continued support for these sectors in the draft five-year plan comes as the EU outlined its own measures intended to limit China’s hold on clean-energy industries, driven by accusations of “unfair competition” from Chinese firms.
China is unlikely to crack down on clean-tech production capacity, Dr Rebecca Nadin, director of the Centre for Geopolitics of Change at ODI Global, tells Carbon Brief. She says:
“Beijing is treating overcapacity in solar and smart EVs as a strategic choice, not a policy error…and is prepared to pour investment into these sectors to cement global market share, jobs and technological leverage.”
Dellatte echoes these comments, noting that it is “striking” that the plan “barely addresses the issue of industrial overcapacity in clean technologies”, with the focus firmly on “scaling production and deployment”.
At the same time, China is actively positioning itself to be a prominent voice in climate diplomacy and a champion of proactive climate action.
This is clear from the first line in a section on providing “global public goods”. It says:
“As a responsible major country, China will play a more active role in addressing global challenges such as climate change.”
The plan notes that China will “actively participate in and steer [引领] global climate governance”, in line with the principle of “common,but differentiated responsibilities”.
This echoes similar language from last year’s government work report, Yao tells Carbon Brief, demonstrating a “clear willingness” to guide global negotiations. But she notes that this “remains an aspiration that’s yet to be made concrete”. She adds:
“China has always favored collective leadership, so its vision of leadership is never a lone one.”
The country will “deepen south-south cooperation on climate change”, the plan says. In an earlier section on “opening up”, it also notes that China will explore “new avenues for collaboration in green development” with global partners as part of its “Belt and Road Initiative”.
China is “doubling down” on a narrative that it is a “responsible major power” and “champion of south-south climate cooperation”, Nadin says, such as by “presenting its clean‑tech exports and finance as global public goods”. She says:
“China will arrive at future COPs casting itself as the indispensable climate leader for the global south…even though its new five‑year plan still puts growth, energy security and coal ahead of faster emissions cuts at home.”
What else does the plan cover?
The impact of extreme weather – particularly floods – remains a key concern in the plan.
China must “refine” its climate adaptation framework and “enhance its resilience to climate change, particularly extreme-weather events”, it says.
China also aims to “strengthen construction of a national water network” over the next five years in order to help prevent floods and droughts.
An article published a few days before the plan in the state-run newspaper China Daily noted that, “as global warming intensifies, extreme weather events – including torrential rains, severe convective storms, and typhoons – have become more frequent, widespread and severe”.
The plan also touches on critical minerals used for low-carbon technologies. These will likely remain a geopolitical flashpoint, with China saying it will focus during the next five years on “intensifying” exploration and “establishing” a reserve for critical minerals. This reserve will focus on “scarce” energy minerals and critical minerals, as well as other “advantageous mineral resources”.
Dellatte says that this could mean the “competition in the energy transition will increasingly be about control over mineral supply chains”.
Other low-carbon policies listed in the five-year plan include expanding coverage of China’s mandatory carbon market and further developing its voluntary carbon market.
China will “strengthen monitoring and control” of non-CO2 greenhouse gases, the plan says, as well as implementing projects “targeting methane, nitrous oxide and hydrofluorocarbons” in sectors such as coal mining, agriculture and chemicals.
This will create “capacity” for reducing emissions by 30m tonnes of CO2 equivalent, it adds.
Meanwhile, China will develop rules for carbon footprint accounting and push for internationally recognised accounting standards.
It will enhance reform of power markets over the next five years and improve the trading mechanism for green electricity certificates.
It will also “promote” adoption of low-carbon lifestyles and decarbonisation of transport, as well as working to advance electrification of freight and shipping.
The post Q&A: What does China’s 15th ‘five-year plan’ mean for climate change? appeared first on Carbon Brief.
Q&A: What does China’s 15th ‘five-year plan’ mean for climate change?
-
Greenhouse Gases7 months ago
Guest post: Why China is still building new coal – and when it might stop
-
Climate Change7 months ago
Guest post: Why China is still building new coal – and when it might stop
-
Greenhouse Gases2 years ago嘉宾来稿:满足中国增长的用电需求 光伏加储能“比新建煤电更实惠”
-
Climate Change2 years ago
Bill Discounting Climate Change in Florida’s Energy Policy Awaits DeSantis’ Approval
-
Climate Change2 years ago嘉宾来稿:满足中国增长的用电需求 光伏加储能“比新建煤电更实惠”
-
Climate Change Videos2 years ago
The toxic gas flares fuelling Nigeria’s climate change – BBC News
-
Carbon Footprint2 years agoUS SEC’s Climate Disclosure Rules Spur Renewed Interest in Carbon Credits
-
Renewable Energy2 years ago
GAF Energy Completes Construction of Second Manufacturing Facility









