Connect with us

Published

on

The EU could be investing tens of billions of euros each year into activities that damage biodiversity, according to a new report from WWF.  

With biodiversity declining at an unprecedented rate around the world, the EU intends to put nature on a “path to recovery” by 2030, in line with global goals. 

Finance is a key part of this and the bloc has pledged to raise at least €20bn in nature funding each year by the end of the decade. 

However, a new report estimates that EU countries could be spending between €34-48bn each year on projects that can end up damaging biodiversity in sectors such as agriculture, forestry and fisheries. 

It is “pretty shocking” to see the potential scale of funding that EU countries are “pouring into harmful practices”, the lead author of the report tells Carbon Brief.  

A policy expert, who was not involved in the report, says the findings may increase pressure on the EU to track its harmful subsidies, but criticised some of what the report counted as ‘“harmful”. 

Tackling harmful subsidies 

There is no standard definition for “biodiversity-harmful subsidies”, but, essentially, they are government incentives that supplement income or lower costs for certain activities that end up damaging biodiversity. 

Agriculture, fishery and energy subsidies are most commonly termed “harmful”, but damage can also be caused by subsidies for other sectors, including forestry, infrastructure, transport, construction and water. 

Subsidies that harm nature and the environment cost the world around $1.8tn each year, according to a 2022 report from two coalition industry groups – equivalent to the entire GDP of Canada.

There are a number of global goals in place to reduce these harmful subsidies. 

The Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, the global deal for nature signed at the UN COP15 biodiversity summit in 2022, includes a target to cut biodiversity-harming incentives, including subsidies, by at least $500bn per year by 2030. The target also aims to identify such incentives by 2025, although the EU has so far not done so. 

The new analysis finds that the EU is allocating between €34-48bn every year to subsidise activities that harm biodiversity. The table below shows the upper and lower estimates for each sector examined. 

Sector Lower estimate of biodiversity harmful subsidies (€) Upper estimate of biodiversity harmful subsidies (€)
Agriculture and forestry 31.35bn 32.57bn
Fisheries 60m 140m
Transport infrastructure 1.69bn 14.07bn
Water 1.33bn 2.09bn
Total 34.43bn 48.87bn

This largest proportion of funding comes from the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), the EU’s farming-subsidy programme, which accounts for almost one-third of the bloc’s total budget. (See “agricultural impact” below.) 

The subsidies include funds that support “unsustainable” farming, land-use changes, river fragmentation and deforestation, according to the report. It adds that these activities can have knock-on effects on biodiversity, including habitat loss, ecosystem degradation and species extinction. 

Prof Alan Matthews, a European agricultural policy expert at Trinity College Dublin, says the findings start a “good debate” about measuring these subsidies. He tells Carbon Brief: 

“I see the report as contributing to the pressure on the EU…to actually come up with its own identification of what the subsidies are, so that they can begin then in the next few years to actually reduce them.” 

Direct links 

The study, conducted by the Netherlands-based economics consultancy Trinomics for WWF, looks at the biodiversity-harming elements of the EU’s long-term budget, the 2021-27 Multiannual Financial Framework. 

It focuses on direct financing for the agricultural, forestry, fishery, transport and water sectors that may be damaging to biodiversity. This financing includes grants, loans and direct payments. 

It does not look at indirect subsidies, such as tax breaks, or infrastructure investments that disproportionately benefit certain industries, such as tax reductions on fertilisers. 

Tycho Vandermaesen, the policy and strategy director at WWF EU and lead author of the report, says there is an overlap between subsidies that damage biodiversity and those that exacerbate climate change, such as fossil fuel subsidies. But the climate impacts were not examined in the report. He says: 

“We have taken a very conscious choice here to only look at biodiversity-harmful subsidies because this is one of the most under-highlighted environmentally harmful subsidies – in contrast to climate or fossil-fuel subsidies, which have by now been well researched.” 

Matthews notes that the overall findings of the report are in line with previous research, but he criticises some parts of the methodology, such as including a very wide range of direct payments for farmers, as potentially harmful.

In response, Vandermaesen says the assumption on the harmful nature of direct payments for farmers is based on findings in existing studies. 

On Monday, the EU Council approved a targeted review of the CAP to assess, among other things, plans to give farmers “greater flexibility” to comply with environmental terms for their direct payments. 

The report is clear that there are uncertainties and a lack of up-to-date information on EU spending in some sectors. It says the findings are estimates and that more comprehensive analysis would be required to fully measure these subsidies. 

Agricultural impact 

Agriculture and forestry receive the most funding for biodiversity-damaging activities out of any sector examined in the report, as shown in the chart below. 

Comparison of potential BHS across analysed sectors (annually)
The lower (left) and upper (right) estimates of funding potentially spent each year from the EU’s long-term budget on biodiversity harmful subsidies, broken down by sector: agriculture and forestry (teal), transport infrastructure (beige), fisheries (brown) and water infrastructure (blue). Source: WWF (2024).

The report notes that several EU funds “allocate money in a way that encourages large-scale unsustainable farming or forestry practices”.

These include direct farmer payments based on farm size, which can incentivise boosting industrial livestock numbers and expanding conventional crop production – “both of which harm the environment”, according to the report.

It estimates that around 60% of CAP funding – meaning more than €30bn each year – can be considered harmful to biodiversity. 

The current CAP plan, which took effect in 2023 and will remain until 2027, included more environmental measures than previous iterations of the policy. But critics told Carbon Brief in 2021 that the plan was riddled with “loopholes” and unlikely to bring significant change to the sector.

Agriculture accounts for more than 10% of the EU’s greenhouse gas emissions. Globally, the sector is also a key driver of forest loss, causing 80% of deforestation as forest lands are cleared to make space for livestock, palm oil and soya beans.

Looking at other sectors, the report outlines that 5-12% of the European Maritime, Fisheries and Aquaculture Fund – a fishery funding programme – is put towards biodiversity-harmful subsidies. 

This is up to 2.5 times higher than the money from this fund aiming to protect and restore biodiversity, the report says. 

The report says it is “challenging” to accurately estimate the impact that building transport infrastructure can have on biodiversity, noting that it can fragment habitats and ecosystems. It estimates that the EU spends anywhere between €1.7bn and €14bn each year on roads, railways and other transport infrastructure that could be harmful to biodiversity.  

Funds used for certain water infrastructure, such as flood control dams, could also harm biodiversity, the research notes. 

Making changes

The report contains a number of recommendations to put an end to these subsidies, including implementing a legally binding framework to phase out biodiversity-harmful subsidies on both EU and national levels. It adds: 

“Inclusiveness and social awareness need to be included in the phase-out of biodiversity-harmful subsidies to avoid regions or industries being left behind or struggling with the transition.” 

Vandermaesen says that consulting with the impacted sectors and giving a clear pathway to diverting these subsidies is a “really important” step. He adds: 

“We do not want to see a situation where, from one day to the next, these subsidies are basically stopped without the involvement of these communities.” 

The report recommends diverting the funding instead for public investments to protect and restore ecosystems and to put in place “ambitious” national biodiversity plans ahead of the COP16 biodiversity summit, which is scheduled to be hosted by Colombia later this year.

Grazing cows on Monte Sambucaro, Italy.
Grazing cows on Monte Sambucaro in Italy. Credit: Antonio Nardelli / Alamy Stock Photo

WWF recently asked European political parties whether they would commit to redirecting fossil fuel and other environmentally harmful subsidies towards the “green transition”. All parties that responded expressed a readiness to redirect these subsidies, but the NGO says that “only a few have committed to enshrining this redirection into law”. 

The subsidies report includes a number of case studies of nature-harming subsidies across Europe. 

A forest recovery plan in France, financed partly by the EU, has had “adverse effects” on forests, the report outlines. Almost nine out of 10 projects financed by the plan in 2021 and 2022 involved clearcutting of trees, which can weaken ecosystems. 

The report details another example in Bulgaria, where farmers were permitted to let animals graze in areas of the country’s national parks to help preserve open areas. 

This led to “vegetation being trampled, water being polluted and wildlife being disturbed”, the report says. To mitigate these effects, park administrations requested €760,000 from the country’s EU-funded environment programme. 

These examples “illustrate how complex it can be actually on the ground to deliver these positive results”, Matthews says, adding: 

“In quite a number of the case studies, actually the subsidies were intended to be positive for biodiversity. But it seems that the way they were implemented…They had these sort of perverse outcomes.” 

The post EU spending up to €48bn on nature-harming activities each year, report says appeared first on Carbon Brief.

EU spending up to €48bn on nature-harming activities each year, report says

Continue Reading

Climate Change

COP31 Bulletin Day 13: New draft retains electrification goal but delays adaptation finance and science decisions

Published

on

After an evening of tense discussions, a new version of the cover text was finally released at around 2am on Sunday morning. But, with many delegates flying home, it is unclear if – and for how long – there will be the two-thirds of governments present needed to legally adopt a decision.

The latest draft, which is – as of 9.30 – scheduled to be put to a plenary session for approval at 10am – retains a goal to boost electrification and links it more strongly with clean energy and storage. It does not, however, include language on transitioning away from fossil fuels as many countries had called for.

It ditches a specific numerical target for carbon capture, use and storage (CCUS), a controversial technology that is favoured by fossil fuel producers, which is now only an aim “to achieve gigatonne scale globally by 2035 as a collective global aspiration”. The previous version had two alternative targets, a weaker one of 0.5Gt “working towards” 1.3-2.5Gt and a stronger one of 2.5Gt.

The draft cover decision has strong language on responding to an almost certain overshoot of the 1.5C warming limit, recognising that it will increase loss and damage and result “in increasingly adverse, and in some cases irreversible, impacts and risks to human and natural systems”. As President of Negotiations Chris Bowen has repeatedly drawn attention to, this is the first COP held since the UN acknowledged that overshoot is inevitable.

In pursuing efforts to limit any overshoot, the decision recognises the need for “deep, rapid and sustained reductions in greenhouse gas emissions in line with 1.5 °C pathways” – which is a push towards greater ambition.

The text also resolves to close adaptation gaps and boost action and support to help countries and communities to better cope with adverse climate impacts. But it does not put a figure to a goal agreed at COP30 last year to triple adaptation finance by 2035.

The goal did not specify a baseline year and African nations, least-developed countries and small island states had pushed for it to be a later and higher baseline and therefore a larger target number of $120 bn a year. Instead, the text launches a “roadmap” on adaptation finance to be considered at COP32.

Loss and damage finance has been cut from the roadmap’s scope, as have references to about half the money pledged to the loss and damage fund having yet to be sent to the fund’s bank account and the gap between the $2.8 billion of loss and damage funding requested by developing countries in the fund’s start-up stage and the $0.342 billion allocated to fund these projects. “Erasing the shortfall doesn’t make it disappear for families who have lost everything”, said Harjeet Singh, global convenor of Fill the Fund.

The new text drops its invitation to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) to publish all of its next three reports in time for the 2028 global stocktake of climate progress. Instead, it just invites them to “continue to provide policy-relevant information as input to the UNFCCC processes, including outputs from the seventh assessment cycle to the next global stocktake”. It no longer specifies that all their reports, including the third on reducing emissions, are published. The IPCC will have an online meeting in December to discuss this issue but COP31 guidance will be influential in its decision.

As Climate Home News entered the venue around 7.30am, tired-looking negotiators from Saudi Arabia and from the Alliance of Small Island Developing States were seen entering the area which houses the Presidency’s offices, as others dozed on sofas. A source close to the German delegation said that negotiations had been intense and were not necessarily resolved.

If the Presidency does not think it can get agreement on a cover text, then it can withdraw it or it can issue it a Presidency declaration, which does not have much weight. Some of its provisions could be added into other agenda items and adopted seperately. Governments could also decide to reconvene COP31 at a later date – known as a bis – as happened at COP6.

The post COP31 Bulletin Day 13: New draft retains electrification goal but delays adaptation finance and science decisions appeared first on Climate Home News.

COP31 Bulletin Day 13: Germany rejects text moments before plenary meeting

Continue Reading

Climate Change

COP31 Bulletin Day 12: ‘Don’t ignore us,’ Panama warns as COP31 runs into overtime

Published

on

On Friday night, COP31 approved a series of less controversial agenda items and then COP President Murat Kurum told governments to hang around the venue until midnight in case his team wanted to consult them on the cover text, which is still Thursday’s version.

If you don’t hear from us, Kurum said, go home and get some rest and don’t bother coming in before 9am. Governments appear to have taken his advice. Around 10am, the conference centre was ghostly and there was still no sign of a new draft cover text.

COP31 Bulletin Day 11: Countries decry cover text for omitting fossil fuels 

Friday night’s plenary did offer a few moments of drama. An activist was ushered out of the room by security after holding a rope around his neck and shouting “you keep doing nothing, nothing at all” and “you are killing the future, just kill me now” to a smattering of applause.

An activist stages a lone protest in the COP31 plenary room during a session on November 20, 2026. (Photo: © UN Climate Change – Kiara Worth)

An activist stages a lone protest in the COP31 plenary room during a session on November 20, 2026. (Photo: © UN Climate Change – Kiara Worth)

Panama’s environment minister Juan Carlos Navarro urged Kurum to ensure full respect of the rules of procedure when gavelling decisions through this weekend. Given he has led threats to object to the cover text if it is not ambitious enough, this sounded like a warning to Kurum not to ignore objections, as previous COP presidents have been accused of doing.

Another significant development on Friday night was a joint statement from Australia and China which, among other things, expressed China’s backing for the 35×35 electrification goal. More on that here.

The post COP31 Bulletin Day 12: ‘Don’t ignore us,’ Panama warns as COP31 runs into overtime appeared first on Climate Home News.

COP31 Bulletin Day 12: ‘Don’t ignore us,’ Panama warns as COP31 runs into overtime

Continue Reading

Climate Change

COP31 is shaping up to be a disaster – not only because it’s weak on fossil fuels

Published

on

“Fossil fuels dumped from latest draft deal at climate summit.” “Ambition goes missing as fossil fuel language drops from draft deal.” “Anger as COP31 draft climate deal removes all mentions of fossil fuels.” These are a few selected headlines about the COP31 climate negotiations as they are due to draw to a close this weekend  – and they hoto: © UN Climate Change – Kiara Worth)all miss the point.

Yes, the UN climate negotiations should address fossil fuels, the primary driver of the climate crisis. But there are many other key issues at play in the negotiations.

Yes, COP31 is shaping up to be a disastrous failure for people and the planet, especially frontline communities in the Global South. But it’s because of much more than the absence of language on fossil fuel phaseout.

COP31 Bulletin Day 11: Countries decry cover text for omitting fossil fuels 

The UN climate negotiations are premised on the idea that the countries of the Global North, which have built their wealth on the backs of heavily polluting fossil fuel-based economies, must do two main things: reduce their emissions and provide support for poorer countries of the Global South. Enabled by climate finance from the Global North, Global South countries should transition much faster to clean, sustainable economies than they would be able to do otherwise.

In addition, given their climate inaction of the past many decades – including ongoing and, in some cases, increasing use of fossil fuels – those Global North countries must also pay to support adaptation to future climate impacts, as well as to respond to loss and damage from climate shocks and stresses that have already happened.

Bad-faith negotiating

On August 26, catastrophic warming-driven glacial floods hit Nepal, with some 1,500 people dead and over 5,000 still missing. Almost exactly two months later, EU climate commissioner Wopke Hoekstra said that any new pledges for climate finance to support countries like Nepal were “dead in the water.”

This comment was shocking for how callous and tone-deaf it was. But it was also shocking because it was the EU openly declaring that they were coming to the COP31 negotiations with nothing to offer – that they would have no intent to negotiate in good faith. Without finance from rich developed countries, the UN climate regime simply does not, and cannot, work.

This is the real story of the failure of COP31. The actual negotiating deliverables for this year’s climate summit include a work programme on climate finance, an institution to support countries to design just transition plans, and progress on adaptation goals supported by adaptation finance. Across all of these negotiating tracks, developed countries led by the EU have done nothing but bullying and blocking.

It is deeply unfair and incoherent for developed countries to call for quicker fossil fuel phaseout in poorer countries while denying those countries the support they need to deliver.

This position becomes even more nonsensical when considering that developed countries’ claims to “leadership” on fossil fuel phaseout are built on lies. The “roadmaps” for transitioning away from fossil fuels that some of these countries have announced are nothing more than repackaged existing policies – exercises in public relations rather than serious plans for change.

Ugandan oil official welcomes transition roadmap as nation gears up for exports

Why the broader story matters

A singular focus on the lack of fossil fuel outcomes – which were not actually on the agenda for the COP31 negotiations – conveniently blurs the story of EU and Global North bad faith out of the picture. It allows the rich countries to do their usual blame game, pointing the finger at Saudi Arabia and similar countries (ignoring the fact that it is actually the United States that has, by far, the world’s largest oil and gas expansion plans).

A political signal in the COP31 text reiterating the importance of phasing out fossil fuels would be very useful (though it would be deeply undermined by language around carbon capture and storage that does exist in the text and must be removed). But that is not actually what this year’s negotiations are about.

Finance, adaptation, and just transition are among the major negotiating tracks at COP31. On each one of these tracks, rich countries have been stonewalling at every turn. Not only are they refusing to fulfill their obligations, they are undermining future obligations and pointing the finger at anyone but themselves when a weak negotiating outcome is the result.

We should be outraged at the lack of progress in phasing out fossil fuels, but we cannot lose sight of the real blockers of progress in the broader geopolitics of the UN climate talks. Saying climate finance is “dead in the water” weeks before negotiations even begin? The EU taking up the mantle of climate villain now that the Trump-led US is out of the picture? That’s the real scandal.

The post COP31 is shaping up to be a disaster – not only because it’s weak on fossil fuels appeared first on Climate Home News.

COP31 is shaping up to be a disaster – not only because it’s weak on fossil fuels

Continue Reading