In the face of accelerating climate change, policymakers and scientists are increasingly recognizing the value of Indigenous knowledge in developing effective climate strategies. This intersection of traditional wisdom and modern science represents a powerful approach to understanding and addressing environmental challenges. However, bridging these two knowledge systems is not without its complexities and challenges.
Understanding Indigenous Knowledge
Indigenous knowledge, also known as Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK), is a cumulative body of knowledge, practices, and beliefs about the relationship between living beings and their environment. This knowledge has been developed over millennia through direct contact with the natural world and passed down through generations.
Dr. Deborah McGregor, an Anishinaabe researcher and Associate Professor at York University, explains, “Indigenous knowledge is not just about understanding nature; it’s about understanding our place within it. It’s holistic, considering the interconnectedness of all things.”
The Strengths of Western Science
Western science, with its emphasis on empirical observation, measurement, and repeatability, has provided us with crucial insights into climate change. From tracking global temperature rises to modeling future climate scenarios, scientific research has been instrumental in identifying and quantifying the challenges we face.
The Power of Integration
Combining Indigenous knowledge with Western scientific approaches can lead to more comprehensive and effective climate policies. This integration brings several key benefits:
- Long-term Observational Data: Indigenous communities have been observing and adapting to environmental changes for thousands of years, providing valuable long-term data that can complement scientific records.
- Localized Knowledge: While Western science often focuses on broad patterns, Indigenous knowledge provides detailed, location-specific insights that are crucial for developing targeted adaptation strategies.
- Holistic Perspective: Indigenous worldviews often emphasize the interconnectedness of environmental, social, and cultural factors, encouraging more comprehensive policy approaches.
- Adaptive Management: Traditional practices often involve adaptive management techniques that can inform flexible, responsive climate policies.
Case Studies in Integration
The Arctic: Inuit Knowledge and Climate Science
In the rapidly changing Arctic, Inuit knowledge has proven invaluable in understanding and responding to climate impacts. The SmartICE program in Nunatsiavut, Labrador, exemplifies this integration.
Trevor Bell, the program’s founder, describes the approach: “SmartICE combines Inuit knowledge of sea ice with satellite data and in-situ sensors. This not only provides more accurate ice safety information but also validates and preserves traditional knowledge.”
Forest Management in British Columbia
In British Columbia, the integration of Indigenous fire management practices with modern forestry techniques is reshaping approaches to wildfire prevention and forest health.
Satnam Manhas, Forest Ecologist with the Heiltsuk Integrated Resource Management Department, shares, “By incorporating traditional burning practices into our forest management plans, we’re not just reducing wildfire risk; we’re also promoting biodiversity and forest resilience in ways that purely scientific approaches might miss.”
Challenges in Integration
While the benefits of integrating Indigenous knowledge and Western science are clear, significant challenges remain:
- Power Dynamics: Historical and ongoing colonial structures often privilege Western scientific knowledge over Indigenous wisdom.
- Different Worldviews: Indigenous and Western scientific worldviews can differ fundamentally, making integration complex.
- Intellectual Property Concerns: There are valid concerns about the appropriation and misuse of Indigenous knowledge.
- Methodology Differences: Western science’s emphasis on replicability and quantitative data can clash with the often qualitative, context-specific nature of Indigenous knowledge.
Overcoming Barriers: Towards True Collaboration
To address these challenges and foster genuine integration, several approaches are being developed:
Ethical Frameworks for Collaboration
(Image Credit: Getty Images, Licensed from Unsplash+)
Many institutions are developing ethical guidelines for working with Indigenous knowledge. The First Nations Information Governance Centre’s OCAP® principles (Ownership, Control, Access, and Possession) provide a framework for how Indigenous data should be collected, protected, used, or shared.
Co-development of Research
Increasingly, climate research projects are being co-developed with Indigenous communities from the outset. This ensures that Indigenous perspectives and priorities are centred in the research process.
Dr. Gleb Raygorodetsky, Executive Director of the Indigenous Knowledge, Climate Change and Biocultural Diversity initiative at the University of Victoria, emphasizes, “It’s not about Western researchers simply consulting Indigenous communities. It’s about true co-creation of knowledge, where Indigenous people are full partners in every stage of the research process.”
Policy Frameworks for Knowledge Integration
Some jurisdictions are developing policy frameworks that mandate the inclusion of Indigenous knowledge in environmental decision-making. In Canada, the Impact Assessment Act of 2019 requires the consideration of Indigenous knowledge in federal impact assessments.
Indigenous Knowledge in International Climate Policy
The integration of Indigenous knowledge is gaining recognition at the international level. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has increasingly incorporated Indigenous knowledge in its assessment reports, acknowledging its value in understanding climate impacts and developing adaptation strategies.
Victoria Tauli-Corpuz, former UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, notes, “Including Indigenous knowledge in global climate policies isn’t just about better environmental management. It’s about recognizing Indigenous peoples’ rights and their crucial role in protecting biodiversity and mitigating climate change.”
Education and Capacity Building
Bridging Indigenous and Western scientific knowledge systems also requires changes in education and training. Some universities are developing programs that teach both Indigenous and Western scientific approaches to environmental management.
The University of British Columbia’s Indigenous Land Stewardship program is one such example. Program director Janelle Kuntz explains, “We’re training the next generation of environmental managers to work effectively across knowledge systems, respecting and integrating both Indigenous and Western approaches.”
The Way Forward: Co-existence and Mutual Respect
True integration of Indigenous knowledge and Western science in climate policy requires more than just incorporating traditional practices into existing frameworks. It calls for a fundamental shift in how we view knowledge creation and environmental stewardship.
Elder Albert Marshall of the Mi’kmaq Nation articulated this through the concept of “Two-Eyed Seeing”: “We need to learn to see from one eye with the strengths of Indigenous ways of knowing, and from the other eye with the strengths of Western ways of knowing, and then learn to use both of these eyes together.”
A Holistic Approach to Climate Change
As we face the unprecedented challenge of climate change, the integration of Indigenous knowledge and Western science offers a path towards more comprehensive, effective, and just climate policies. This approach not only enhances our understanding of environmental changes but also promotes more sustainable and equitable ways of relating to the natural world.
The journey of integrating these knowledge systems is ongoing, requiring patience, respect, and a willingness to challenge long-held assumptions. However, the potential rewards – in terms of more effective climate strategies, preservation of cultural wisdom, and a more holistic approach to environmental stewardship – are immense.
In the words of Winona LaDuke, Anishinaabe environmentalist and economist, “We don’t have time to argue about whose knowledge system is superior. We need all the wisdom we can get to face the climate crisis. It’s time to listen to the land and to those who have lived in harmony with it for millennia.”
As we move forward in our fight against climate change, this integration of knowledge systems offers not just hope for more effective policies but a model for how different ways of knowing can come together to address the greatest challenge of our time.
Blog by Rye Karonhiowanen Barberstock
(Header Image Credit: ThisIsEngineering, Licensed from Unsplash)
The post Bridging Two Worlds: Integrating Indigenous Knowledge and Western Science in Climate Policy appeared first on Indigenous Climate Hub.
Bridging Two Worlds: Integrating Indigenous Knowledge and Western Science in Climate Policy
Climate Change
States Say They Need More Help Replacing Lead Pipes. Congress May Cut the Funding Instead.
The U.S. House voted to cut millions promised for the work this year. The Senate will vote this week, as advocates and some lawmakers push back.
The Senate is taking up a spending package passed by the House of Representatives that would cut $125 million in funding promised this year to replace toxic lead pipes.
States Say They Need More Help Replacing Lead Pipes. Congress May Cut the Funding Instead.
Here are 6 inspiring books discussing oceans, critiques of capitalism, the Indigenous fight for environmental justice, and hope—for your upcoming reading list this year.
The Deepest Map: The High-Stakes Race to Chart the World’s Oceans
by Laura Trethewey (2023)
This book reminds me of the statement saying that people hear more about the moon and other planets in space than what lies beneath Earth’s oceans, which are often cited as ‘scary’ and ‘harsh’. Through investigative and in-depth reportage, ocean journalist and writer Laura Trethewey tackles important aspects of ocean mapping.
The mapping and exploration can be very useful to understand more about the oceans and to learn how we can protect them. On the other hand, thanks to neoliberal capitalism, it can potentially lead to commercial exploitation and mass industrialisation of this most mysterious ecosystem of our world.
The Deepest Map is not as intimidating as it sounds. Instead, it’s more exciting than I anticipated as it shows us more discoveries we may little know of: interrelated issues between seafloor mapping, geopolitical implications, ocean exploitation due to commercial interest, and climate change.
The Code of Capital: How the Law Creates Wealth and Inequality
by Katharina Pistor (2019)
Through The Code of Capital, Katharina Pistor talks about the correlation between law and the creation of wealth and inequality. She noted that though the wealthy love to claim hard work and skills as reasons why they easily significantly generate their fortunes, their accumulation of wealth would not last long without legal coding.
“The law is a powerful tool for social ordering and, if used wisely, has the potential to serve a broad range of social objectives: yet, for reasons and with implications that I attempt to explain, the law has been placed firmly in the service of capital,” she stated.
The book does not only show interesting takes on looking at inequality and the distribution of wealth, but also how those people in power manage to hoard their wealth with certain codes and laws, such as turning land into private property, while lots of people are struggling under the unjust system.
The Intersectional Environmentalist: How to Dismantle Systems of Oppression to Protect People + Planet
by Leah Thomas (2022)
Arguing that capitalism, racism, and other systems of oppression are the drivers of exploitation, activist Leah Thomas focuses on addressing the application of intersectionality to environmental justice through The Intersectional Environmentalist. Marginalised people all over the world are already on the front lines of the worsening climate crisis yet struggling to get justice they deserve.
I echo what she says, as a woman born and raised in Indonesia where clean air and drinkable water are considered luxury in various regions, where the extreme weather events exacerbated by the climate crisis hit the most vulnerable communities (without real mitigation and implementations by the government while oligarchies hijack our resources).
I think this powerful book is aligned with what Greenpeace has been speaking up about for years as well, that social justice and climate justice are deeply intertwined so it’s crucial to fight for both at the same time to help achieve a sustainable future for all.
As Long As Grass Grows
by Dina Gilio-Whitaker (2019)
Starting with the question “what does environmental justice look like when Indigenous people are at the centre?” Dina Gilio-Whitaker takes us to see the complexities of environmental justice and the endless efforts of Indigenous people in Indian country (the lands and communities of Native American tribes) to restore their traditional cultures while healing from the legacy of trauma caused by hundreds of years of Western colonisation.
She emphasizes that what distinguishes Indigenous peoples from colonisers is their unbroken spiritual relationship to their ancestral homelands. “The origin of environmental justice for Indigenous people is dispossession of land in all its forms; injustice is continually reproduced in what is inherently a culturally genocidal structure that systematically erases Indigenous people’s relationships and responsibilities to their ancestral places,” said Gilio-Whitaker.
I believe that the realm of today’s modern environmentalism should include Indigenous communities and learn their history: the resistance, the time-tested climate knowledge systems, their harmony with nature, and most importantly, their crucial role in preserving our planet’s biodiversity.
The Book of Hope
by Jane Goodall and Douglas Abrams with Gail Hudson (2021)
The Book of Hope is a marvelous glimpse into primatologist and global figure Jane Goodall’s life and work. The collaborator of the book, journalist Douglas Abrams, makes this reading experience even more enjoyable by sharing the reflective conversations between them, such as the definition of hope, and how to keep it alive amid difficult times.
Sadly, as we all know, Jane passed away this year. We have lost an incredible human being in the era when we need more someone like her who has inspired millions to care about nature, someone whose wisdom radiated warmth and compassion. Though she’s no longer with us, her legacy to spread hope stays.
Ocean: Earth’s Last Wilderness
by David Attenborough and Colin Butfield (2025)
“I could only have dreamed of recording in the early stages of my career, and we have changed the ocean so profoundly that the next hundred years could either witness a mass extinction of ocean life or a spectacular recovery.”
The legend David Attenborough highlights how much humans have yet to understand the ocean in his latest book with Colin Butfield. The first part of it begins with what has happened in a blue whale’s lifetime. Later it takes us to coral reefs, the deep of the ocean, kelp forest, mangroves, even Arctic, Oceanic seamounts, and Southern Ocean. The book contains powerful stories and scientific facts that will inspire ocean lovers, those who love to learn more about this ecosystem, and those who are willing to help protect our Earth.
To me, this book is not only about the wonder of the ocean, but also about hope to protect our planet. Just like what Attenborough believes: the more people understand nature, the greater our hope of saving it.
Kezia Rynita is a Content Editor for Greenpeace International, based in Indonesia.
The Whanganui River is officially a living being and legal person. Māori leaders explain how Indigenous knowledge and persistence made it happen.
Ned Tapa has spent his life along New Zealand’s Whanganui River. For Tapa, a Māori leader, the river is not a resource to be managed or a commodity to be owned. It is an ancestor. A living being. A life force.
‘I Am the River’: How Indigenous Knowledge Reshaped New Zealand’s Law
-
Greenhouse Gases5 months ago
Guest post: Why China is still building new coal – and when it might stop
-
Climate Change5 months ago
Guest post: Why China is still building new coal – and when it might stop
-
Greenhouse Gases2 years ago嘉宾来稿：满足中国增长的用电需求 光伏加储能“比新建煤电更实惠”
-
Climate Change2 years ago
Spanish-language misinformation on renewable energy spreads online, report shows
-
Climate Change Videos2 years ago
The toxic gas flares fuelling Nigeria’s climate change – BBC News
-
Climate Change2 years ago嘉宾来稿：满足中国增长的用电需求 光伏加储能“比新建煤电更实惠”
-
Climate Change2 years ago
Bill Discounting Climate Change in Florida’s Energy Policy Awaits DeSantis’ Approval
-
Carbon Footprint2 years agoUS SEC’s Climate Disclosure Rules Spur Renewed Interest in Carbon Credits