Connect with us

Published

on

After a five-year long legal battle, the Constitutional Court of South Africa has blocked Shell and local partner Impact Africa’s permit to explore for oil and gas off the country’s East Coast, in a landmark victory for local communities and civil society.

“Today’s judgment makes me feel very happy and proud that the ocean is not for profit for mining companies,” said East Coast resident and environmental campaigner Siyabonga Ndovela.

The verdict culminates a years-long process in which non-profits Sustaining the Wild Coast, Natural Justice, Greenpeace Africa, and others took legal action against Shell, Impact Africa and the South African government for failing to consult affected communities – a legal requirement in the country.

The Constitutional Court ruled that Shell and Impact Africa had not complied with resource governance law, had failed to meaningfully conduct public consultation and had failed to consider the impact on climate change, cultural rights, livelihoods and ecological harm.

The ruling references last year’s landmark advisory opinion by the International Court of Justice, which states that countries have a legal duty to prevent and repair damage to the climate system. The South African judges argued climate change “transcends borders” and that states’ obligations “must be understood within the broader framework of international law.”

“This case must also be understood against the backdrop of well-documented struggles by coastal communities to protect their land, marine resources and ways of life in the face of extractive activities that they believe threaten their very existence,” wrote Justice Narandran Kollapen.

Protesters march to the Constitutional Court in 2025 (Photo: Ihsaan Haffejee/GroundUp)

The Constitutional Court found that the exploration right had been unlawfully granted by the Department of Mineral and Petroleum Resources.The ruling upholds a 2022 regional court decision against Shell and overturns a 2024 appeal that allowed the company to conduct fresh public consultations under the original exploration right. Today’s decision means the right, initially granted in 2014, must be set aside.

Celebrating the decision, Sherelee Odyar, oil and gas campaigner at Greenpeace Africa, told Climate Home News that the court confirmed “serious failures” in the awarding of exploration rights to Shell and Impact Africa, which “can not simply be corrected later”.

The Wild Coast is a biodiversity hotspot which has been conserved over generations by coastal communities who rely on the ocean and land. “Our land and sea are central to our livelihoods and our way of life. Over generations we have conserved them, and they have conserved us,” reads the founding statement in the case. 

A Shell spokesperson said it noted the ruling, responding that “we are committed to responsible offshore exploration, meaningful stakeholder engagement and environmental stewardship.”

The Department of Mineral and Petroleum Resources did not respond to requests for comment at the time of publication.

“Renewed strength” for communities

The ruling adds to a series of legal challenges brought by civil society groups against oil companies and the government as South Africa has expanded oil and gas development since 2014 under Operation Phakisa, a plan aimed at “unlocking the economic potential of the oceans”.

On the West Coast, Walter Steenkamp, Chair of Aukotowa Fisheries Cooperative, which is involved in a separate ongoing legal action against TotalEnergies, said that “today’s court case gave me renewed strength.”

The case could also set a precedent for future oil developments, said Alessandro Mazzi, legal governance researcher at the University of Wageningen. He added that the verdict “sends a strong signal to investors that where projects affect people’s land, livelihoods and environment, meaningful consultation and genuine ecological assessment are an integral part of responsible investment”.

Janet Solomon, coordinator of advocacy group Oceans not Oil, said that the Court’s emphasis on democratic participation, culture, livelihoods and the health of future generations in handing down the verdict signals a shift in jurisprudence on environmental governance, saying that this focus “may prove to be the judgment’s most enduring legacy.”

The post South Africa’s top court blocks Shell’s offshore oil exploration right appeared first on Climate Home News.

South Africa’s top court blocks Shell’s offshore oil exploration right

Continue Reading

Climate Change

Countries take up industry push to loosen UN carbon market rules at COP31

Published

on

Dozens of countries – from big emerging economies to the world’s poorest nations – are calling for the UN’s new carbon market to reassess climate integrity rules, in a push that campaigners and researchers have blamed on industry lobbying.

At COP31 talks on the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism (PACM) this weekend, the Like-Minded Developing Countries – a group that includes Saudi Arabia, India and China – the Least Developed Countries (LDCs) and landlocked developing countries raised concerns about the requirements project developers must meet, according to sources familiar with the closed-door discussions.

They warned about the cumulative weight of those requirements developed under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement as barriers to implementation. Several countries, including Singapore and some Latin American states, said rules must keep projects financially viable, while South Korea asked for proportionate requirements, the sources said.

Their demands closely track arguments from carbon market industry groups, which claim PACM’s conservative approach to counting emission reductions is so strict that few projects will ever come to fruition.

Industry and NGOs lobby to weaken UN carbon credit rules in “coordinated” push

In a letter published ahead of COP31, the lobby groups asked governments to “raise implementation concerns” and to request that the Supervisory Body – the UN body that oversees the market – assess the “combined impact” of its rules on the feasibility of projects.

The letter was signed by the International Emissions Trading Association (IETA), a business group whose members include fossil fuel giants Shell, BP, Saudi Aramco and Chevron, along with the Project Developer Forum and the Wildlife Conservation Society, which develops forest conservation programmes.

Draft text reflects industry demands

Those demands are reflected in the first draft of the COP31 decision on the mechanism, published late on Saturday. To guard against over-crediting, PACM’s rules deliberately err on the side of issuing fewer credits when emissions cuts from projects are uncertain.

The document asks the Supervisory Body to look at how these cautious assumptions add up across its rules and what that means for the number of credits, project costs and prices. The aim, it says, is to avoid “excessive compounding of conservative adjustments”.

Other parts of the draft tell the body not to make its rules too cautious or too rigid. That includes efforts to guard against the risk that carbon captured by a project is later released. Most of these passages add that environmental integrity must be maintained.

Risk of another ‘failure’

“Weakening the rules is not climate ambition – it is a license to pollute,” said Erika Lennon, a senior attorney at the Center for International Environmental Law (CIEL). “As we are on the brink of permanently breaching 1.5C, we cannot afford to turn the carbon market into another loophole for polluters,” she added.

Axel Michaelowa, research director at Perspectives Climate Research, said that if attempts to weaken the rules succeed, it could lead to another failure of an international carbon market. Demand for credits rests on trust, he said, and the slightest doubt over integrity erodes buyers’ willingness to pay.

Calls to revise requirements “must be supported by scientific evidence, not unsupported claims of under-crediting – especially when these assumptions come from private actors whose revenues depend on the volume of transacted credits rather than real mitigation outcomes,” Michaelowa said.

The EU, Switzerland and Senegal are among a handful of countries pushing back against demands to re-assess the market rules, according to the sources, and are opposing requests to weigh up the profitability of projects or to lower standards.

Burn company enumerator Teresia Wanjiru checks moisture on firewood at a client’s house using clean cookstoves in Kachoroba village of Kiambu county, Kenya, August 16, 2023. REUTERS/Monicah Mwangi

Burn company enumerator Teresia Wanjiru checks moisture on firewood at a client’s house using clean cookstoves in Kachoroba village of Kiambu county, Kenya, August 16, 2023. REUTERS/Monicah Mwangi

Cookstove credits in focus

At the centre of the fight are new methodologies for projects that aim to cut emissions by distributing cleaner cookstoves – one of the carbon market’s most popular credit types and also one of its most criticised for overstating climate benefits. A 2024 study in Nature Sustainability found cookstove projects had been over-credited roughly tenfold.

Under the rules adopted by the Supervisory Body in October, cookstove project developers are required to set aside part of their credits in a buffer pool, in case the forests they claim to save later burn or are cleared.

The body rejected an exemption from this requirement sought by developers, corporate buyers, some conservation groups and the UN Environment Programme, in what critics called a coordinated lobbying campaign, as reported by Climate Home News.

Industry groups and some countries have seized on the cookstove methodologies to warn against excessively stringent requirements, which they say undercount emission reductions and deter developers. The LDCs told negotiators that developers had found some approved methodologies, including on clean cooking, difficult to apply.

Industry group calls for revisions

Industry representatives attacked the Supervisory Body’s approach in interventions that sources in the room described as very aggressive.

In a subsequent Linkedin post, IETA’s Andrea Bonzanni accused the regulator of following an unscientific approach that would deliver systematic under-crediting. He called on environmental integrity standards to be amended and rulebooks to be revised.

The mechanism “has had a false start”, he said, but countries in Antalya have a chance to agree on clear guidance that puts it back on track. “Unless the mechanism becomes workable across countries and activity types, its impact on the atmosphere risks remaining marginal,” he added.

IETA did not respond to a request for comment.

    Campaigners and researchers have pushed back on the claims. Arguing there is currently no evidence of under-crediting in the UN market, they stressed that more credits do not necessarily mean more emissions reductions if the rules underpinning them are not grounded on science.

    “Having a Paris Agreement carbon crediting mechanism that cheats the atmosphere completely misses the point,” said Isa Mulder, a policy expert at Carbon Market Watch. “Countries should not allow Article 6 to become just another dangerous distraction from real, urgent climate action.”

    The draft of the rules is an early version and will be negotiated during the COP31 summit’s final days. Under the Paris Agreement rules, the Supervisory Body must follow guidance that governments give through COP decisions.

    The post Countries take up industry push to loosen UN carbon market rules at COP31 appeared first on Climate Home News.

    Countries take up industry push to loosen UN carbon market rules at COP31

    Continue Reading

    Climate Change

    COP31’s electricity goal must be about more than AI and luxuries for the rich

    Published

    on

    Mohamed Adow is director of Power Shift Africa.

    International Energy Agency chief Fatih Birol celebrates the electricity demands of AI and electric cars, but the revolution must be about more than luxuries for the rich. It must bring clean, affordable power to the hundreds of millions still living without it.

    The world is entering the age of electrification. But while wealthy countries focus on powering AI data centres, electric cars and other energy-hungry technologies, hundreds of millions of people across Africa and the developing world still lack access to electricity.

    The real promise of the electricity revolution is not simply meeting the growing demands of those who already have plenty, but bringing clean, affordable power to those who have none.

    So the decision by Türkiye and Australia to make electrification a flagship initiative at COP31 should be welcomed. Their proposed 35 by 35 goal, increasing electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35 per cent by 2035, could accelerate this transformation.

    But who is this revolution actually for? Birol has celebrated the arrival of the electricity age, identifying AI data centres, electric transport and air conditioning as three major drivers of growing electricity demand.

      These technologies are reshaping the global energy system. But it is extraordinary that a discussion about the world’s electricity future can focus on infrastructure and services for the rich while overlooking those who still have no electric power at all.

      For wealthy countries, electrification may mean powering AI or replacing petrol cars with electric ones. For millions across Africa and the developing world, it means something more fundamental: being able to turn on a light, refrigerate food and run a hospital or a business.

      The electrification revolution cannot simply meet the growing energy demands of those who already have plenty. It must deliver electricity to those who have none.

      A dirty energy goal?

      There is another serious flaw in the COP31 proposal. It promotes electrification without ensuring that additional electricity comes from renewable sources or replaces fossil fuels.

      Electrification is not automatically decarbonisation. A factory switching from coal to renewable electricity is a climate achievement. But building new gas-fired power stations to meet rising demand can increase electrification while prolonging fossil fuel dependence.

      At COP28 in Dubai, governments agreed to transition away from fossil fuels. COP31 should be taking that commitment forward, not creating a target that could be achieved without delivering it.

      For wealthy economies, electrification largely means replacing existing technologies. Petrol cars become electric vehicles. Gas boilers become heat pumps.

      For Africa, the challenge is different. More than 600 million Africans still lack electricity. We are not simply replacing one energy system with another. In many places, we are building one that does not yet exist.

      How clean energy can boost business for Africa’s food producers

      The electricity needed to power another data centre in a wealthy country should not count as a greater achievement than electricity powering a rural African hospital for the first time. Yet a global target focused purely on consumption makes no distinction between the two.

      Africa possesses 60% of the world’s best solar resources, yet receives just 2% of global clean energy investment. That imbalance illustrates how far we remain from an equitable energy transition.

      The 35 by 35 target could be achieved through rapid electrification in major economies while hundreds of millions of Africans remain without power. That might count as success on a global spreadsheet, but it would represent a failure of climate justice.

      Money matters

      Perhaps the most troubling weakness of the pledge is its failure to answer the question that matters most for developing countries: who will pay?

      Africa does not lack renewable energy potential. It lacks affordable investment. High borrowing costs make clean energy projects far more expensive than comparable investments in wealthy economies.

      The launch of the Electrify Now Finance Coalition at COP31 is welcome. But creating another coalition is not the same as delivering affordable finance at the scale required. Developing countries cannot embrace ambitious global targets without the means to achieve them.

      Made in Nigeria: The race to build an African solar industry from scratch

      If Türkiye and Australia want 35 by 35 to become a defining achievement of COP31, they must strengthen it.

      The goal must prioritise renewable electricity and the displacement of fossil fuels. It must put universal electricity access at its heart and include credible financing for developing countries.

      The twenty-first century will increasingly be built around electricity. But success cannot simply mean wealthy countries having more electric cars and bigger data centres while hundreds of millions across the Global South remain in the dark.

      The real measure of the electricity revolution is not just how much power the world consumes, but who gets access to it, where it comes from and whose lives it transforms.

      The post COP31’s electricity goal must be about more than AI and luxuries for the rich appeared first on Climate Home News.

      https://www.climatechangenews.com/2026/11/16/cop31s-electricity-goal-must-be-about-more-than-ai-and-luxuries-for-the-rich/

      Continue Reading

      Climate Change

      ‘Everything on the table’: COP31 draft text recognises climate harm, but stronger action needed to phase out fossil fuels

      Published

      on

      In response to the COP31 cover decision draft text, Dr Simon Bradshaw, COP31 Lead at Greenpeace Australia Pacific, said:

      “This first draft of a headline decision from COP31 recognises the escalating climate harms being inflicted on communities around the world and that countries must achieve far deeper and faster cuts to emissions if we’re to keep the goal of limiting warming to 1.5°C alive — a survival line for the Pacific. It also welcomes the landmark ICJ ruling on climate change.

      “The draft calls on countries to accelerate the phase out of coal, oil and gas, including an immediate transition away from fossil fuels in power generation. It stops short of linking the flagship COP31 electrification pledge to the urgent need to phase out fossil fuels.

      “Overall, this is some of the strongest language we’ve seen in a draft COP decision. The question now is how much of it will survive the tough days of negotiations ahead. With four days to go, there is everything on the table here in Antalya. Governments, including Australia, must not lose sight of the urgent and brutal impacts of climate change today, the opportunities of a future beyond fossil fuels, and walk away with a strong cover decision, not a cover up decision.”

      ‘Everything on the table’: COP31 draft text recognises climate harm, but stronger action needed to phase out fossil fuels

      Continue Reading

      Trending

      Copyright © 2022 BreakingClimateChange.com