Connect with us

Published

on

Weather Guard Lightning Tech

Why Wind Works (But Not in the US)

Why Wind Works (But Not in the US)

And a lesson from the Wright Brothers.

Wind, solar, hydro, nuclear, and geothermal energy have all been tagged as “alternative’ energies for most of my lifetime, and it’s done all of us a great disservice.

To be clear, when I say “us,” I’m looking at my fellow US citizens.

How, and Why, Wind Works

There’s no shame in not understanding how wind energy works. Not being willing to give something a try because you don’t understand it? Now that’s a real shame. Because that’s how we get left behind. That’s how we get dependent on people (countries) (and I’m looking at China) who are willing to use “new” technologies to run rings around us.

I put “new” in quotes because China is just one of many developed nations that have been using wind, and other “alternative” energies, to heat homes, fuel growth and power their military for more than 25 years. Add Australia, Denmark to that list and put a star next to Brazil, for coming on strong in the past decade.

Here’s why they’re laughing at us – all the way to the bank.

The Best Arguments Against Wind

The most common arguments against wind energy that come from people who are not wind energy engineers – and that includes about 100% of our politicians at a local, state, and federal level. Their primary argument? That wind is not a consistent power supply.

That’s true. The wind does not blow strongly enough, constantly, to provide power when we need it.

But coal doesn’t feed itself into a furnace, either. 

Every energy source must be transmitted, metered, and used at some point after it has been generated. You (and your elected representatives) don’t need to be able to diagram an electrical grid to understand energy.  You don’t need to understand how wind energy works to understand that we need it. Now.

Our current reliance on coal, natural gas, and to some degree, oil, to power our homes and factories has been dubbed “cheap” and “easy” because the infrastructure was built for those fuels. It will take some work to convert systems to manage wind-generated power.

But here’s the thing. We don’t have to figure out the technology – as noted above, the rest of the world is doing it. We’re not, so we’re falling behind.

What the Wright brothers did was a little harder. Remember them?

Two Dayton, Ohio boys thought they could fly. It took a lot of work. For the first 10+ years they tried, people said they were crazy. When they made it work, people scoffed and said we’d never need airplanes.

When it started to look attractive, some smart leaders said, “we should invest in airports.” And to this day, you can see the economic benefits those first airports brought to towns, large and small, all over the country. And to the world.

What if they’d listened to the naysayers? What if someone in China took the design and said, let’s have a go with this?

What if other countries didn’t build airports? We’d be flying rings around them.

Let’s not be the neanderthals who get left behind.

This is an opinion piece by Weather Guard Lightning Tech CEO Allen Hall. Occasional articles and other industry news content like this is sent to subscribers of the Weather Guard Substack channel. The Weather Guard Substack subscription is free. Sign up here.

Join the conversation about Wind Energy – the industry and the innovations – on our LinkedIn page.

https://weatherguardwind.com/why-wind-works-but-not-in-the-us/

Continue Reading

Renewable Energy

Homeschooling

Published

on

Decent and intelligent people respect the rights of parents to homeschool their children, but there are two reasons for concern: a) socialization, failure to expose children to their peers, so that they may make friends and come to understand the norms of society, and b) the quality of the education itself.

Almost all homeschooling in the United States is conducted on the basis of a radical rightwing viewpoint, normally a blend of evangelical Christianity and Trumpism.

Homeschooling

Continue Reading

Renewable Energy

The Positive Effects We’ve Had on Others Are Profound, Whether We Know It or Not

Published

on

There’s a theory that most people underestimate the positive effects they’ve had on other people.

Yes, that’s the theme of “It’s a Wonderful Life,” but it’s also the core of the 1995 film “Mr. Holland’s Opus,” in which a music teacher who deemed that his life had been a failure because he never completed writing a great symphony, is gently and beautifully corrected. Please see below.

The Positive Effects We’ve Had on Others Are Profound, Whether We Know It or Not

Continue Reading

Renewable Energy

Renewable Energy Concepts Can’t Violate the Laws of Physics

Published

on

In the early days of 2GreenEnergy, my people and I were vigorously engaged in finding solid ideas in cleantech that needed funding in order to move forward.

I vividly remember a conversation with a guy in Maryland who was trying to explain the (ostensible) breakthrough that he and his team had made in hydrokinetics. When I was having trouble visualizing what we was talking about, he asked me to “think of it as a river in a box.”

“Oh!” I exclaimed. “You mean you take a box full of standing water, add energy to it get it moving, then extract that energy, leaving you with more energy that you added to it.”

“Exactly.”

I politely explained that the laws of physics, specifically the first and second laws of thermodynamics, make this impossible.

He wasn’t through, however, and insisted that, in his office, his people had constructed a “working model.”

Here’s where my tone descended into something less than 100% polite. I told him that he may think he has a working model, but he’s wrong; if he believes this, he’s ignorant; if he doesn’t, but is conducting this conversation anyway, he’s a fraud.

“But don’t you want to come see it?” he implored.

“No. Not only would not fly across the country to see whatever it is you claim to have built, I wouldn’t walk across the street to a “working model” of something that is theoretically impossible.”

I tell this story because the claim made at the upper left is essentially identical.  You’re pumping water up out of a stream, and then claiming to extract more energy when the water flows back into the stream.

Of course, social media today is rife with complete crap like this.  We’ve devolved to a point where defrauding money out of idiots is rapidly replacing baseball as our national pastime.

Renewable Energy Concepts Can’t Violate the Laws of Physics

Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2022 BreakingClimateChange.com