Connect with us

Published

on

Ministers are now in the building and embarking on the tricky task of refining the mammoth 18-page draft cover text down to something that can be agreed upon by the end of the week.

If Monday’s heads of delegation meeting is anything to go by, this will be a big challenge. According to reporting from the Earth Negotiations Bulletin, which is allowed into the room unlike media, Like-Minded Developing Countries (LMDC) – a group that includes China, India and Saudi Arabia – said the draft crosses their red lines.

Particularly, they object to the inclusion of the 35×35 electrification target, the roadmap on transitioning away from fossil fuels and calls to rapidly reduce methane. The Arab Group and Russia went further, rejecting the draft text entirely over similar concerns.

Even Türkiye’s ally Azerbaijan criticised the draft, ENB reports, while developed countries look to have stayed relatively quiet. The text currently contains most of their key asks, including on responding to an overshoot of 1.5C and acknowledging the latest science, but also calls on them to reach net zero emissions by 2030, which is very unlikely to fly.

COP31 Bulletin Day 7: Incoming ministers set to battle over cover text

Negotiations on the cover decision will resume late this afternoon. Other developments of note include concerns about the fate of the Climate Finance Work Programme (CFWP), with the poorest countries wanting it to continue for two more years and to include a goal to triple adaptation finance. The EU and Switzerland have called for no text on this item, not wanting to take on new financial commitments.

NGOs under Climate Action Network International issued a letter calling on ministers and the COP31 presidency to ensure the CFWP addresses developing countries’ needs for grant-based, highly concessional public finance for adaptation, loss and damage, emissions reductions and just transition. ”A weak or procedural result only, or worse, no text at all, would represent a failure and undermine the Paris Agreement’s finance architecture,” it said.

    Elsewhere, the EU is set to announce it is backing the voluntary pledge to boost electrification to 35% of final energy use by 2035.

    Tuesday is Oceans Day at COP31, with discussions and events due to focus on increasing cooperation between countries to protect oceans and including measures in national climate plans. There’s also likely to be a fresh push by some countries on the importance of climate science feeding into international policy and on driving forward the shift away from fossil fuels.

    COP31 set to boost ocean protection – marine geoengineering too?

    One aspect of the cover decision which is likely to prove relatively uncontroversial are its references to the importance of the ocean, which are pleasing campaigners.

    Asked how such words will actually protect marine ecosystems, David Ryfisch, senior manager at the Climate Policy Initiative, said the words will send a signal to politicians as well as to the private sector.

    “We will need the insurers, the institutional investors, banks, etc, to provide the financing, because a lot of funding will be necessary,” he told journalists on Oceans Day at COP31.

    Areas which need funding, he said, include sustainable fisheries, coastal protections and cleaning up the shipping industry. Standing alongside him, young Samoan activist Brianna Fruean spoke of a project she saw at the pre-COP in Fiji where the villagers of Naidiri have stopped fishing in an area of their waters and are re-planting coral that has been bleached.

    All the planters are volunteers though, she told Climate Home News, squeezing it in around their day jobs. With funding, they could be paid for their work and restore the reef much faster. The project began in 2009.

    At a separate event on Indian cooperation with small island developing states on ocean conservation, India’s environment minister Bhupender Yadav talked up his country’s mangrove restoration efforts.

    India’s environment minister Bhupender Yadav (left) speaks at an event on Indian cooperation with small island developing states on oceans on 17 November 2026 at COP31 (Photo: Joe Lo)

    A more controversial climate solution involving the seas is marine geoengineering, which means fiddling with the oceans so they store even more carbon dioxide than they already do.

    Some ocean advocates support this – or at least research into it. Kilaparti Ramakrishna, oceans and climate advisor at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, told Climate Home News in September that research should be conducted into ocean alkalinity enhancement and ocean iron fertilisation, where iron is put in the ocean so that algae grows on it and sucks up carbon.

    “Those are the kinds of things that make the ocean a hero in terms of solving the climate problem, but we should always be mindful that in solving one problem, we don’t create other problems,” he said.

    On Tuesday, however, Marine Lecerf, head of international policy at Ocean and Climate Platform, was wary about marine carbon removal techniques. “There are many uncertainties surrounding their effectiveness, their scalability, their durability – but even more importantly, their potential adverse impact on nature,” she said.

    There is wording in the cover text on carbon dioxide removal in general, which Lecerf opposes, saying the link between this and oceans has not and should not be made.

    Former Canadian environment minister Steven Guilbeault said the focus should instead be on ocean solutions that have already been proven to work. “We can perhaps another day talk about those technologies if we’re going to need them,” he said.

    Corals depicted during a WCS-Fiji Survey 2020 (Photo: Tom Vierus)

    The post COP31 Bulletin Day 8: Arab Group, Russia reject cover text over fossil fuels and electrification goal  appeared first on Climate Home News.

    COP31 Bulletin Day 8: Arab Group, Russia reject cover text over fossil fuels and electrification goal 

    Continue Reading

    Climate Change

    Revealed: Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are largest CO2 exporters of all time

    Published

    on

    Russia, Saudi Arabia and COP31 co-president Australia are the largest exporters of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions in history, reveals Carbon Brief analysis.

    Since 1850, the three nations – and other major fossil-fuel exporters – have exported hundreds of billions of tonnes of CO2 in the form of gas, oil and coal that has been burned in other countries.

    Carbon Brief’s analysis of extraction-based CO2 emissions is based on figures compiled by Robbie Andrew, a senior researcher at Norwegian climate institute CICERO.

    It shows that Australia is responsible for more than twice as much global warming when including emissions from its fossil-fuel exports, while Saudi Arabia has caused more than four times as much.

    Australia has been under pressure for continuing to expand its fossil-fuel production ahead of the UN climate summit in Antalya, where it is co-president with host nation Turkey.

    Membership

    Support award-winning climate journalism


    Join CB+

    In contrast, nations that are heavily reliant on energy imports – such as Japan or Germany – have are responsible for far lower shares of planet-warming emissions, if responsibility passes to fossil-fuel producers.

    There are many different ways to assign historical responsibility for current global warming.

    Carbon Brief has previously published analysis based on territorial emissions, the consumption of imported goods, according to colonial rule or based on historical emissions per capita.

    Historical responsibility

    This year is expected to be around 1.5C hotter than pre-industrial temperatures. Next year is forecast to be the hottest on record, at around 1.7C of warming.

    This year-to-year variation is due to natural variability, such as El Niño. However, approximately 100% of global warming to date is the result of human-caused greenhouse gas emissions.

    The burning of fossil fuels since the industrial revolution is the largest contributor to this.

    Since there is a direct link between each tonne of CO2 and each fraction of a degree of warming, historical fossil-fuel emissions can be tied to responsibility for current climate change.

    This is typically calculated on the basis of historical territorial CO2 emissions, according to where in the world the fossil fuels are burned. It is also possible to assign historical responsibility on a “consumption” basis, according to where goods are used.

    Historical emissions are often counted by country, but this puts the focus on populous nations. Alternatively, responsibility can be assigned per capita, based on today’s populations.

    A less-familiar way to look at the question of historical responsibility is to consider where fossil fuels are extracted. This puts the spotlight on major fossil-fuel exporters.

    The figure below shows that Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are the largest CO2 exporters of all time, based on emissions from exported fossil fuels since 1850.

    (The allocation is based on extraction taking place within current national borders. Emissions under the former USSR, Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia are allocated among constituent countries, based on their share of emissions at the time of separation.)

    Bar chart titled "Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia are the largest CO2 exporters of all time"

    Other major CO2 exporters, based on their overseas sales of fossil fuels since 1850, include Venezuela, Iran, Norway, the United Arab Emirates and Canada.

    Between them, these major coal, oil and gas producers have exported hundreds of billions of tonnes of CO2 over the past 175 years, according to Carbon Brief’s analysis.

    Extraction-based accounting

    The analysis shows that overall, the US and China retain the largest responsibility for historical warming under extraction-based accounting, despite having been net CO2 importers since 1850.

    The US has large resources of coal, oil and gas, but was nevertheless a major oil importer until after the shale revolution in the early 2000s.

    China remains a major oil and gas importer, describing itself as “rich in coal, lacking oil and gas”.

    Russia remains in third place, as shown in the figure below, despite gaining responsibility for an extra 69bn tonnes of CO2 from exported fossil fuels.

    The UK becomes the fourth-largest historical emitter, climbing above Germany due to the latter’s reliance on fossil-fuel imports.

    Saudi Arabia becomes responsible for the world’s fifth-largest share of historical warming when including its fossil-fuel exports, which increase its cumulative emissions more than fourfold.

    Bar chart titled "Saudi Arabia is the fifth-largest contributor to current global warming when accounting for its fossil-fuel exports"

    Australia also climbs up the rankings, becoming one of the top-ten largest emitters when including its fossil-fuel exports. This more than doubles its share of historical emissions.

    Nations that drop down the rankings under extraction-based accounting, due to their reliance on fossil-fuel imports, include Germany, India, France and COP31 host Turkey.

    Japan is a particularly notable example, as it is almost completely reliant on fossil-fuel imports. The nation is the sixth-largest emitter on a territorial basis and the 34th-largest on an extraction basis.

    Per-capita accounting

    When considering population sizes, major fossil-fuel exporters have the highest extraction-based CO2 emissions since 1850, as shown in the figure below.

    Small nations that export large amounts of oil and gas are particularly prominent on this list, including Brunei, Kuwait, Qatar, Norway and Trinidad and Tobago.

    Bar chart titled "Major fossil-fuel exporters have the highest historical extraction-based CO2 emissions per person"

    Andrew tells Carbon Brief that while the extraction-based accounting offers an alternative perspective on historical responsibility for warming, it also raises complex questions. He explains:

    “At the end of the day, it’s not solely the responsibility of extracting countries that fuels are combusted; it’s joint responsibility between extractors, producers and consumers.”

    He adds that responsibility for past decisions is shared by many actors. For example, he notes that oil production in the Middle East was historically “developed by and for western powers”.